Thread:LucidPigeons/@comment-26884760-20160125192510/@comment-26205772-20160125192955

It depends on if his insanity is shown to affect him as a person or not. Can he distinct between good and evil? Is the insanity ever played in a way that affects his concept of morality? Someone like the Joker who actively embraces who they are and (as shown in The Killing Joke) is still actually capable of realizing that they are deeply insane? They can count. But, ask yourself this; would Contagion still be a villain if he wasn't criminally insane?

Normally, I'd be tempted to say no right off the bat, but there are several cases like Contagion in the universe of Marvel (and DC, for that matter) and they still count as Monsters. So, it'd really depend on whether or not his insanity affects his morality or moral judgment; if it doesn't, I think he can be listed.