User blog comment:Queen Misery/PE Proposal: Mister Chuckle Teeth/@comment-28775608-20190718044836/@comment-28775608-20190718163042

I don't compare it to CSM because he is an different level of PE regarding this one shot villain, there is no comparison between and it would be unfair for Chuckleteeth.

However, i compare him with another X Files one shot villain who is already PE and for the same reason than Chuckleteeth (since the only actual heinous enough thing they both did was murdering kids)

Yes, other demons in the series have been shown to have clear moral agency (Daemonicus, Terms of Endearment) but you forget that monster of the week episodes rarely, if ever have relation to each other, each one tells a different story without following the original series and thus should be treated as separated media.

In the case of Chuckleteeth we can't not treat him as other demons of the series, because he has no relation with them, and i go back with the same: we have not clear that he has moral agency. The only thing that makes me doubt is that as you said, it seems that he is trying to punish the witch by murdering kids, but does he does it for fun? or because he doesn't know anything else but killing?

Also, the aftermath is really not shown at all, we never had a chance to see the complete gruesome work of Chuckleteeth on his Hellhound form (which is normal on this series, but still), which is a shame because that would make a difference to break the heinous standards and make him higher than Lee Roche.

Thrash Man was REALLY a game breaker on the series, because this is one of the few times on we can actually see how the villains do the dirty work (and in a really violent, gruesome).

Too bad he was just a mindless golem