Thread:AustinDR/@comment-27960787-20170317163245/@comment-2175012-20170317172348

1. If there's an alternative version of Voldemort wherein he isn't evil, I would say that the original one still counts.

2. Depends on the work and how it portrays their actions. If their well-intentioned mentality doesn't mend well with the narrative - as in they are portrayed as horrific by the other characters - then I believe that they count as long as they don't mitigating factors.

3. If by impact you mean flashbacks showing the aftermath ir something like that, then I'd be cautious to say yes. Offscreen Villainy in general is a disqualifier, because it's an informed attribute that doesn't rely on show don't tell.

4. I don't have much knowledge on video games, so I can't really comment there.