Thread:AustinDR/@comment-27586321-20141115161342/@comment-27818776-20141115162649

It's hard to say. Sure, Katz is probably more active than Scar. What I mean by this is that he actively tried to kill people, and he had succeeded in some cases. Katz is a very dark villain, because he is essentially a mass murderer/serial killer, and unlike with Scar, Katz never sought to take over the land where he was standing on. He simply wanted to kill people because he was a pure sadist.

Scar is also probably as bad as Katz, except, he only killed his brother and attempted to kill his nephew. Scar not only murdered his own brother, but he also psychologically abused his own nephew into thinking that he killed Mufasa, and then told him to run away from the Pride Lands and to never return. He even told his hyena henchman to kill him anyway because he was quite simply a dick. While that's bad by itself, what really makes Scar a monster in my eyes is that he condemned all of his subjects to starve to death instead of doing the smart thing and telling them to relocate. Not only that, but when he publicly tried to execute his nephew, he told him that he murdered his father all while gloating about it. To basically sum Scar up, he betrayed his family, he betrayed his pride, he betrayed his loyal henchman, and he only cared about himself.

Overall, I can't really say who is more evil in this situation. They are both equally vile, in my opinion, at least.