Thread:StarWizardWars/@comment-15895329-20131219214654/@comment-15895329-20131220155513

Anyway, reopening the discussion. Here's my case for why the edits needed to be made:

The Info-Box: Again, an apalling number of inaccuracies. Nihilus is not "the master of the Dark Side". Most of his occupations listed present him as the single greatest villain in Star Wars which is quite simply wrong. More to the point Nihilus has never been referred to as any of those aliases in a canon work. Now perhaps he was referred to as them in the non-canon version but this then is all the more reason why we should seperate the pages and thus prevent confusion. Because if you're thinking of "fan Nihilus" then that's perfectly fine. But we need to differentiate between them then.

Finally, Nihilus does not have "immeasurable power". Nihilus is not the most powerful Dark Force user and in fact is nowhere CLOSE to the top of the food-chain.

On to Categories (which I will say I'm pleased you removed some):

Not a Magnificent Bastard. He is not particularly cunning or shown to be terribly intelligent (also meaning he is not a Mastermind or Evil Genius either) and also lacks charm or charisma. He fits none of the crieria and therefore he is not one.

Not a Social Darwinist or Megalomaniac. He does not show the mentality of either one. Now it is true that he is technically a Sith, who are traditionally both of these things, but it needs to be rememebered that Nihilus as he is really doesn't care about Sith teachings or in fact much of anything beyond sating his hunger and in fact would have eventually devoured the other Sith when he ran out of other food sources.

Not an Evil Ruler or Dictator as he does not fit the crieria for either one. Being in charge does not automatically make you a dictator.

Is a traitor, as he betrayed Darth Traya.

Is Enigmatic, as we know little about who he was prior to becoming Nihilus and in the game proper it is hard to know much about him beyond the basics due to his refusal to speak a word of english.

Finally, listing both Murderer and Mass Murderer is redundant. I also question whether or not he meets the definition of serial killer.

Well, that's my piece. If you disagree with any of it, please tell me why specifically. Also, if the corrected parts do indeed pertain to "fan Nihilus" then I see that as the clearest proof that we need to seperate the pages, because otherwise it will just confuse people.