Thread:Panzysoldat/@comment-31330278-20190725214555/@comment-31330278-20190730175226

1A. He's a single child in the canon. But let's think for a second about a fanfic where he have a sibling. I know Pamela is a devoted mother, but not all devoted mothers are devoted to all children equally. Do you see yourself reading that kind of fanfic?

1B. He killed only one innocent. Latavious. Actually the least brutal kill of the season. Of course he's sympathetic to a certain extent, being a psychopath and all, but he still have a great motive and valid tragedy. If you disregard Motherface's motive, then Harlemface have the best one. The fact he had plans to turn on Beth, maybe even informed the cops before his death (she knew he wanted to do it, but maybe he already did), makes him even better. If you were a psychopath, do you see yourself working with Jamal? Assuming, of course, you won't anything Beth would do.

2. I thought the same, until Beth came up from the blow to the head. Only then I realized it's her, because only killers and Dewey can survive a direct brain damage. I wish Liv was the killer instead though. She had what it takes, more sophisticated (I believe Beth secretly knew it) and would have a better motive. If she was a killer in your version, which motive would you give her? And how would you like her to kill Beth in that alternative season?

3. Did this guy hurt you, or just showed signs? What did he do that indicate on being on the anti-social spectrum?

4. For the first section, it's likely (or at least possible) that Maggie knew it's Kevin and they staged a fight so no one would suspect. The second section might be explained by either bad writing or by Brandon realized Kevin framed him, and therefore thinking about his revenge.

5. If he didn't do it, then he did got more than he deserved. But if he did what they say he did, he deserved no better than being burned. If we assume the rumors about him aren't confirmed, does it mean he was framed?

6. It was implied many times. While Cotton did had sex with Maureen before the murder, It's easier to frame someone at the victim was raped for real. Beside that, there are some evidences. First, the part where they slashed her groin. That's the kind of things people do only during a rape or fending off a sexual assault. Billy himself had a twisted connection between sex and domination, as shown when he pressured Sidney into doing things so he could mark a V before killing her, and when he rambled about Maureen being a "slut bag whore". There's also the possibility that one of Billy's motive was possessiveness toward Sidney ("a dead Sidney won't leave me"), which is a mindset of people who either commit rape or just fine with the concept. Stu tried to rape Sidney at his final moments. It can't be his first time raping someone. When he said "we put her out of her misery, cause let's face it, Sidney, your mother was no Sharon Stone", he refer to raping her ("her misery") and then killing her as their concept of mercy. Maybe I forgot some evidences, but this is what I can think about at the moment.