User blog comment:Valkerone/PE Proposal - Karl Tanner/@comment-31330278-20200116155059

My goodness yes. Tanner is a mass murderer who led at least one gang rape and do many of the horrible things he do because he's a petty son of a thousand. Plus, he forced people to watch his gang rapes. Even in GOW standards, his tragedy of being born a cripple and abused by Craster ain't holding water. Craster was the teacher, and Tanner was a great student. His cruelty toward Bran and his friends just because he assumed they are noblemen is similar to Dr. Facilier's approach, but of course, much more graphic and dangerous. Being cruel to people who were kind to him definitely doesn't help. As far as I know, his ungratefulness wasn't even for measurable gain. Some of the other villains (such as Joffrey and the mad king) can claim they are insane. Tanner had no mental illness, at least nothing notable. Thank goodness John Snow killed him when he did, and at the way he killed him.