User blog comment:Ducktales37/PE Proposal - The Father from IWBTG/@comment-31330278-20191217144340/@comment-34055410-20191218001617

Crimes aren’t the only deciding factors when it comes to being PE. Calling child murder and patricide heinous is like saying the grass is green. It goes without saying. But the reason so many people are voting no is because the character is hardly given any characterization. He seems more like a GDV, if anything. And as for the offscreen villainy, the reason other villains still count despite committing their crimes offscreen is because there is actually onscreen evidence. In this scenario, do we actually see any evidence beyond the crimes merely being stated? And unfortunately, yes, in some works (like this one), the crimes you mentioned can be played for laughs. There are literally works where rape is played for comedy, so.