User blog comment:Magma MK-II/Characters that shouldn't be here, Part 4: Electric Boogaloo/@comment-25008763-20160112134608/@comment-7455247-20160126185705

If a human living in the wild hunts animals for his sustenance, then no, he's not evil... unless the animals are sentient (and especially if they are the main characters). Whether or not he knows it doesn't change anything, if he doesn't then he's Obliviously Evil and can be considered as an Anti-Villain or even as a Designated Villain, but he's still a villain. Same thing for animals.

Plus, like I said before, every stories are created by humans, therefore no animals can be portrayed perfectly like in real-life, so in a sense they all behave in a manner abnormal to their nature (after all, almost all of them are made to be enemies of the protagonists). For this reason, the vileness of any of them can be debated since we can find some abnormal behaviors in all of them, as small it may be.

Finally, I ask it once again, even if they are not considered as evil, why not accept them in this Wiki anyway ? Until not long ago, this Wiki accepted even characters who are not really evil as long as they have the bad guys' role in the story. Not to mention the fact that there are plenty of other characters in this Wiki who are not really evil but who are still here (and nobody cares about them).