User blog comment:Looperreallyreallysucks/Pure Evil Proposal - Luke Lerner/@comment-27492241-20200223070838/@comment-34055410-20200223140601

Let me analyze everything you just said, Brandon:

“Besides Ashley did act like a jerk towards him...” So that justifies sexually tormenting her and even having her boyfriend killed in front of her? That’s the logic you’re espousing?

“...him calling Garrett an annoyance was to hide his remorse for killing his best friend.” And how do we know that? The only thing we saw was his subverting his remorse for killing Garrett. Nothing else.

“I mean, he even has her heart beat recorded on one of his toys and misses how she tucks him in. When I heard that story, I was crying for him.” What on earth? What is making you think that makes a twelve year old kid who killed and sexually assaulted people sympathetic?

“Also, his only redeeming quality is his love for his mother and pet spider.” Austin refuted that part already.

“Unlike all of you, I'll give him a second chance and I'm writing fanfics about any redemption for him.” Said fanfic wouldn’t even be canon though...and why are you trying to redeem a sociopathic child who killed three people (including his best friend) and spent hours torturing and abusing his babysitter...?

“True, pranking Ashley was a jerk move but she didn't have to say such harsh things.“ Saying harsh things doesn’t exactly justify everything Luke does. At this rate, what I believe you’re trying to say is that if you’re not extremely friendly and patient towards a person 24/7, then you have no rights to be pissed when the person ties you up, molests you, kills two people in front of you, and stabs you in the neck while implicitly getting off from it.

“Also unlike Henry Evans, Luke doesn't harm his mother and gets worried about her reaction to him being a serial killer.” I don’t even need to explain what the fallacy in that argument is. I’ll just let you figure it out for yourself.