Thread:LucidPigeons/@comment-2175012-20160315140658/@comment-26205772-20160316171439

Allow me to skim over each point...

Never mentions his parents? Nothing redeeming there; nothing onscreen we can measure against him.

Punishment? Honestly... he sounds more like a case of a Karma Houdini, and it's almost frighteningly common for real people like Andy to get off with little more than a slap on the wrist. Serial rapist? Have a sex offender registration. You won't be trusted and your careers will be limited, but you still get away with outright rape God-knows how many times over. For me at the least, it's much less him not being treated seriously enough to have a proper punishment and more the book tapping in closer to reality, and it truly is tragic because I know for a fact there are thouesands of Andy Evans lurking in this world, and many will never be punished adequately.

Relationship with Rachel? If she's nothing more than something than Andy to pleasure himself to, there's nothing redeeming there.

Any other points?