Thread:Jester of chaos/@comment-31330278-20180211164358/@comment-4708882-20190410122838

1. I'd think it'd be the equivalent of a prequel given in context as it's establishing on something already established which are always easier to expand the story in a different way IMO. I kind of feel Harry Potter ran its course, the prequels might be good (haven't watched them yet) but it's main timeline doesn't really come across as needing continuation especially sine before the last one it felt complete. With Scar I wouldn't find people who sympathize with him that bad but not much he better especially given he lacks any of the abuse Hitler went through before he became a monster we know from history. The changes for that fanfic sounds awesome, I love Snape as a father figure for Ashi! :)

2. While we don't see I think it might be like Frollo given how he basically had not problems his brother wiping out humanity yet condemned Salem for her far less cruel actions. Glad you like it. :) With Ozpin it'd be a mix, Jester being a sadist and well... Jester might use his reincarnation curse as a "stress ball" for a while until he got bored and it'd be hard to have Ozpin push Anastasia that much after all but if I ever wrote her getting pushed that far it might be interesting.

3A. Don't worry Shi was always written as a nihilist who just so happened to be an atheist, when he finally finds out of the settings genuine Gods he basically just goes "So you exist after all? Fine then I'll prove you're not truly immortal/omnipotent!" with little regard for his own life. He mostly just wants his death to be due to losing in a full on battle vs his body giving out.

3B. I really like the sound of it and I haven't decided how I want Abigail and Richard to grow closer yet. Mine might just be talking and revealing more of their inner thoughts before kissing but that's just a rough idea.

3C. I won't lie I don't remember if you miswrote it earlier, it sounds different enough to me and definitely like a fun read/watch. :)

4. Yeah I just recommend you stay with the other idea as the other might get hard or confusing, anytime on helping after all what are friends for. Yeah the Nucklelavee in hindsight didn't fit the "Police Legends" but glad you can use it for another story. Both could be cool but the only potential problem with a Jersey Devil like creature is given it has wings it might make it harder to imagine him not getting away. Off topic: With Stupidface he always came across as less amoral and more as just someone who'd lie about it to save himself. Reading on Milton he sounds rather evil and like Sidney might be simply pity him much like from what you described like Roman. Yeah scapegoat is someone generally the audience sympathizes with due to their fate being harsher than they had earned, with Milton I'm not sure but trust your judgement. Oh I heard you might be thinking of proposing Sofia Lamb if so and you want I can review the effort post on this thread first then you can post it on discussions after it's reviewed to help. Given she kidnapped kids, cruel experiments on her daughter and planned similar for humanity she can most likely count. The heinous standard of the series is high but given her end goal being arguably the worse and unique probably enough just got to point out she doesn't love her daughter as an individual but not too hard to do. I definitely plan to vote yes at least. Ps: sorry if I rambled a little much on that and/or if you don't want to do that.

5. I would of never guessed Gabriel was originally going to be that way, the story definitely sounded interesting but sometimes we do have to cancel a project but like you were saying doesn't mean we can't use elements from it or recycle it to help current ones.