Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-29275465-20170524055332/@comment-4708882-20170524063051

Well it depends on if they have other powers and if they are written well in general but personally I feel they could be memorable or terrifying. A villain who's too generic might not go well among other things. The ultimate fate can also be what makes them memorable like say being trapped in a Fate Worse than Death could either make the audience sympathize / pity them or if they are made to be so unlikable and or vile the audience might get immense satisfaction knowing that they are in such a situation. If immortal like this it also depends on not only powers but the roles. If it's say a thug or simple henchman it can create a fun ways to show them being reckless and arrogant due to the belief they are invincible, it can allow for cool masterminds who take advantage of multiple life times of knowledge to make complex plans or to master certain skills (magic, martial arts, swordsmanship etc.). Some might still be cowards who prefer to rely on others to do all the dirty work even though they themselves cannot die which can hurt the story depending on the writing in general. Now the drawback could be if the character also has too many other powers or if they don't feel pain or even get worn out. In these cases it can easily feel like the author is just trying to make them seem so cool and might make some poor writing excuse on how they decide to make this villain lose. So in my opinion it can be done well if handled correctly but it could easily be handled poorly all depending on multiple factors.