Thread:Jester of chaos/@comment-5754292-20170408012215/@comment-5754292-20170408203902

See here's my thoughts on the "villain vs antagonist " controversy. The characters that people are debating about,  Ed Rooney,  Walter Peck and Sharpay Evans have all been recognized as villains by other websites. They've all gotten tons of infamy outside of Villains Wiki. If you look up top 10 villains Ed Rooney and Walter Peck have appeared on at least one. Sharpay is debatable. She's been debated for awhile. On the one hand she can be viewed as a antagonist but her songs are recognized as villain songs on TVTropes and on Disney Wiki. I know someone told me that we're going by this wikis policies and not by other websites so ether we have to A, just drop the rules and have the wiki go back to the way it was  (which I know the answer to that choice) or  B really evaluate these antagonists  and really think about if these villains really are evil or wicked.