User blog comment:Magma MK-II/Characters that shouldn't be here, Part 3: Return of the Revenge/@comment-366087-20151230223311

Keeping in mind that the Rules state that this is a Villains Wiki, and it must stay that way, just listing characters with faults is not enough. They need to Pass the Criteria set in the rules, especially Section 6

Fails 3.3 -- no real life villains
 * Becca Swanson
 * Curtis Axel

Fails 6.4 -- no mindwashed/possessed
 * Midnight Sparkle
 * goaded to "unleash the magic" she was temporarily overwhelmed and transformed by it
 * Snips & Snails (unilaterally untagged by Dreadnine)
 * Jerky followers who did not set out to become demons, were transformed by "Midnight Sparkle", herself not in control of her actions
 * Flutterbat
 * Victim of Twilight Sparkle's errant spell
 * Zorpox the Conqueror
 * Mind altered temporarily by a device
 * Black Spiderman
 * under influence of the Venom entity

Fails 6.1-3
 * Bloo
 * Not established by setting, Jerk is not enough
 * Punisher -- {unilaterally untagged by Dreadnine)
 * Not established by setting, on the side of law even if the law does not approve of his methods
 * Dexter Morgan -- (unilaterally untagged by Jester of chaos)
 * Not established by setting, no matter how "realistic" it is; on the side of law, following a moral code instilled in him by a police officer is the OPPOSITE of "immoral", is not a danger to the law-abiding or those which the law handles no matter how much his methods are not approved of
 * Uncle Ruckus --(unilaterally untagged by Robinsonbecky)
 * King of Jerks, sure, but not Wicked/Evil
 * Baseball Bullies
 * Ellen Yin
 * Trish Niedermeyer
 * Greg Heffley
 * not established by setting, is in fact the franchise's protagonist, a youth going through a series of Life Lessons
 * Shadowbolts (Friendship Games)
 * Jerks, Antagonists, not wicked/evil
 * Albertosaurus (Primeval) (and many dinos and animals)
 * non-anthropomorphic animals cannot be "villains", they are following their nature, no matter how much they fit the role of antagonists. Unlike Sharptooth which is set in a world of anthropomorphic animals (even though it never speaks, and could be argued in the setting only herbivores are "people")
 * Sharpay Evans
 * Jerk, antagonist, falls short of wicked/evil
 * Tiara Gold -- ditto
 * Bonnie Rockwaller -- ditto
 * Nina Harper -- ditto
 * Nick (Left 4 Dead)
 * Protagonist and Jerk but trusted by the group
 * Sam Puckett
 * not established by setting and is protagonist; Jerk, not evil /wicked no matter how much (story-moving) conflict she may cause
 * one of the "evidence" is she running a child labor sweat shop. This was one "Aesop" episode in which BOTH she and Carly tried to produce a product cheaper than source and learned they could not. Aesops and learning lessons do not count
 * Sheldon Cooper
 * not established by setting; again, being a jerk is not enough, not Wicked/evil
 * simple question, if a "villain" ''why would the rest still tolerate and be his friend???" That should become a criteria to also measure validity of inclusions