Board Thread:Clean up Concerns/@comment-15895329-20171029005512/@comment-15895329-20171029161131

He's repeatedly killed criminals without a trial in a pre-meditated fashion over and over and over. That's murder. Any court of law would call it murder, the other characters recognize it as such, and it's no different from what Punisher has always done. His actions as the Hood are murder. Not to mention that he kept doing it on and off after Season 1's end.

As for skinning someone alive, what context would excuse such an act? In any case, it wasn't the only way to prevent the planet from blowing up, or a city from being nuked. It was an act of excessive cruelty done while he was fighting common criminals that was so bad it even horrified his fellow criminal Anatoli, who even said that he would associate such an act with Slade Wilson.

And again, how is Catwoman stealing from rich people enough to qualify as a villain, but Oliver skinning someone alive isn't? The latter is far worse than the former.