Sally Reynolds

Sally Reynolds is a hidden villainess from "Weekend Warriors," episode 1.06 of Psych.

She was played by Claire Coffee, who later appeared as Nikki Crawshaw on NCIS, and is best known for playing Adalind Schade on Grimm.

Sally Reynolds is an insurance agent who participated in Carlton Lassiter's Civil War reenactment, playing nurse Jenny Winslow--who lost her husband and two sons in the conflict and killed Captain Quantrill. As shown early in the episode, Sally missed her cue, but Nelson Poe, the actor who played Quantrill, was shot and killed by Griffin Mahoney. It was revealed that Sally was Mahoney's intended target, and with that, Shawn and Gus went undercover as reenactors on the case, with Shawn bonding with Sally.

However, Sally was revealed as a villainess at episode's end, as she and Mahoney had been colluding to rob Mahoney's jewelry store as part of an insurance scam. The attempt on Sally was to prevent Mahoney from splitting the money with her, and Poe was killed because he witnessed Mahoney aiming his shotgun at Sally. The villainess denied the claims, but after evidence of their scam and Mahoney's murderous deeds were uncovered, Sally was arrested along with Mahoney.