Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1705775-20170901162345/@comment-1705775-20170904194808

Loolveus wrote: Shadow has redeemed I'd say (until Forces decided to make him evil again for some dumb reason...) but even being a villain once should still make the character qualify if it had enough of an impact on the story.

if a character was originally designed as a villain then they qualify - look at Juggernaut from X-Men, he is a hero in some works now (like Excalibur).. I don't think that should disqualify the fact he was a violent criminal for a good few decades before he decided to turn "good".