Thread:Love Robin/@comment-26120048-20170218201404/@comment-26120048-20170219122003

Well, not alright, actually. Why was this decision made? Why do we need a seperate definition of Arrowverse than the rest. You simply decided that this was the way to go and, since you became Admin around that time (,I believe,) implemented it. However, I do not see the reason behind that. It is not neccessary for "crossing back and forth like walking through doors" to belong in the same multiverse. The fact that they are in the same multiverse should be enough to warrant Supergirl's edition to the category.

And while the Alien Invasion crossover could have been written without Supergirl, it wasn't. I agree that her episode was just her being taken to Earth-1 but why should that matter. It proves that they are part of the same multiverse and have the potential to interact with each other. And as not every Arrowverse villain neccessary fights heroes on Earth-1, I still think Supergirl should be made part of the Arrowverse on this wiki.

Love Robin wrote:

And yes they should not be tagged with "hero villain". This wikia also does not add "hero villain" tags simply because they make any short brief appearances in the same media as "hero". To be a "Hero Villain" the villain should Ah yes, I forgot about that. So, an addition like "Flash Villain" to Arrowverse Eobard Thawne would be okay?
 * have originated with that hero
 * be the villain most associated with that hero