User blog comment:Modernmyrmidon/PE Proposal: Chara/@comment-32583560-20191116070353/@comment-26277897-20191118012709

How you can be certain they were only using the Dreemurrs? Is it that hard to consider the possibility that they may have genuinely loved them prior? It's not out of the question that they might have came up with their plan because they loved the Dreemurrs and wanted the monsters to be free on the surface. Their actions in the Genocide Route might not be reflective on how they were with the Dreemurrs in the past. Flowey says "No hard feelings about back then, right?" when you're in New Home on Genocide; did Chara truly view them as pawns this whole time, or are they only willing to strike them down because they felt as though Asriel betrayed them, and this is their revenge?

As for Chara being present in the Pacifist and Neutral routes, there's the flavor text when choosing the laugh interaction with Snowdrake's mother in the True Lab, which might suggest Chara being the narrator since they had a similar reaction to Asgore's buttercup poisoning. There's also the memory of Chara meeting Asriel for the first time, which is shown after Frisk is knocked unconscious after falling down to the Garbage Dump in Waterfall. Considering that the memory is interrupted when Frisk wakes up, that would imply Frisk was the one experiencing it, which would be impossible unless Chara was present with them somehow. Also, with the way determination works, it doesn't make sense for them to have been only present in the Genocide Route; Chara states they came back through Frisk's determination, so their essence should've been absorbed by Frisk's body at the beginning of the game, since they landed on their grave; they would've been living within Frisk's body throughout the entire game. That is evidence to suggest that Chara might've been present in all routes, which would also support Chara not being evil in the present game outside of Genocide.