User blog comment:Magma MK-II/Characters that shouldn't be here./@comment-7455247-20150410193543/@comment-7455247-20150411161938

I have some other propositions :

- Puss in Boots (Shrek) : Well, he was an antagonist during less than five minutes and a hero during FOUR films (and a lot of short films). Even Diego (from Ice Age) has been a villain for a longer time. He was clearly made up to be a protagonist, not a villain.

- King Harold : I can understand why he is here, but he's not really evil, he only wanted the better for his daughter and was manipulated by Fairy Godmother. But he didn't like what he done and was very hesitant, so he is more a tragic anti-hero than an evil-doer.

- The Witch (Brave) : She didn't do anything evil, okay she transformed Mor'du and Queen Elinor into bears, but it was more or less what her clients asked to her. There was no evil intents there.

- Were-Rabbit : He was not a true villain, the only person he attacked was Victor Quartermaine (and the vegetables), who clearly deserved it.

- Hal Wilkerson : That's right, he is irresponsible and a bit mad, but he is not really evil. Most of the time he has genuinely good intentions, and at worst he only acts like a jerk, not like a villain.

- Snotlout Jorgenson : He is maybe a bully, an idiot, a jerkass and considers himself as Hiccup's rival, but he is absolutely not a villain. If he is one, the twins are too.

- Hookfang : Ditto (but I never read the books, maybe he is more villainous inside).

- Val-Yor : Despite being a racist, he is in the good guys' side and never acted as an antagonist (he insulted Starfire, nothing more).

- Greta : She is the only gremlins who never did anything evil, it's even said in his page. She pursued Forster to marry him, but since he finally accepted, it doesn't count as an evil act.

- Razoul : Although he seemed to particularly hate Aladdin, technically he was just doing his job, and it's not evil at all to pursue a thief who actually broke the law.

- The Withered Lover : She is the only non-hostile ghost and she is mostly in the protagonists' side, so she is clearly not a villainess.

- Gilbert Huph : If the film was simply a comedy he could have counted, but in a superhero film he can't be really considered as a villain. He was a jerk but he only did his job and didn't do anything really evil.

- Hulk : I don't know every stories about him, but it seems to me that he is a hero most of the time and when he causes some damages it's only in special circumstances.