User blog comment:12345B/PE Proposal: Bill Sykes/@comment-39032584-20190827120229

I'm honestly leaning towards a no. He may be an intimidating loan shark played seriously, but little to none of his actions are out of the ordinary or unexpected for someone in his position, and he doesn't do a lot onscreen. For example, he is not explicitly confirmed to have actually killed anyone; all we know is that he's trained his dogs to do so if necessary. Plus, what others mentioned is pretty valid; he did honor his deal by both giving Fagin in the extra time to get the money and then remove the debt altogether when he had a different way of getting the money, neither of which he had to do. He's a bad man, no doubt, but having a small honorable side and doing little out of the ordinary makes him fail the requirements in my opinion.