Thread:Love Robin/@comment-5754292-20160925163032/@comment-366087-20161111034434

Personally, a "Villain Song" should be one which relates something about their villainy and evil intentions. A villain just singing is not enough for that piece to be a "Villain Song". Especially in music-laden venues. For example, Doofenshmirtz sings quite a few songs, not all of them are "villain songs." The one he sings about his redheaded evil date is. The one about being controlled by a platypus is not.

Singing does not in itself reflect a character's villainy. Especially in musicals. Which is part of why we dropped it as a category/tag.

Bottom line, no, had Transformed Twilight Sparkle/"Midnight Sparkle" broke into a song/Villain Song, it still would not qualify her to be on this wikia because Rule 6.4 still applies: she was temporarily forced into a position where she was possessed/brainwashed/overwhelmed. Unlike Starlight Glimmer who had been a villain for a long time before her debut and spent an entire season seeking revenge and destroying the world before her reformation and redemption.