User blog comment:BigBadSquid/PE Proposal: Pirate Master/@comment-28775608-20200125200124

I'm giving him a weak yes since he falls on off-screen villainy, all of his evilest acts were in the past and we only have mention of it.

However we are talking of games with really silly villains and this guy made a good job standing out (not that it was too hard tho) and he still did horrible things, so yeah i think he qualifies.