User blog comment:Ngh93/What REALLY makes a villain a Complete Monster?/@comment-25008763-20150327151609/@comment-1672596-20150327165751

That's actually one of the major problems I have with the category. And I wouldn't even say it's strict, considering strictness doesn't leave room for any wiggle room, which is the antithesis of it being just other people's opinions. In fact, there are several instances where someone is considered a complete monster and another isn't in the exact same work despite doing exactly the same kinds of things that the CM got the label for (like for example, Volgin and The Boss with their use of the Davy Crocketts in Snake Eater. The former is considered a CM in large part because of he used it to blow up the Sokolov Design Bureau earlier in the game, yet the latter isn't despite doing the exact same thing and with even less of an excuse). I actually want the CM category eliminated precisely BECAUSE it's too broken to work.

The only way a category like that is going to work is in absolutes, 100% rate of success (and no rounding, either, meaning the percentage is exact), no other options. Think gravity. You always fall. Or how about the sun rising in the east always.