Mr. Kreeg

Mr. Kreeg, a Halloween-hating man, lives alone with his dog, Spite, as his only companion. Kreeg shows his disgust for Halloween by scaring away trick-or-treaters.

Bus Driver Story

A school bus containing eight children, all mentally ill to the point of being chained to their seats, crashed into the lake at the bottom of the quarry; the bus driver (Mr. Kreeg) was the only one who survived. Macy reveals that the children's parents paid the bus driver to kill them to end the embarrassment of their "burden". As for the bus, some people say it sank so deep in the lake, it could not be found. Others say the town did not want the bus to be found

The Principal Story
Mr. Kreeg goes outside to see what is the loud noises coming from outside, Kreeg hears is neighbor Wilkins is doing something strange, unknown to the fact he is burying a dead body of a child, and he tells Wilkins to keep his son off his yard Kreeg later goes back inside annoyed. Wilkins sees Kreeg screaming from his window, begging for help, Wilkins disregards this and Kreeg is knocked down by an unknown assailant.

Sam Story

While at his house, Kreeg is attacked by Sam. During the struggle, Kreeg rips off the sack over Sam's head to reveal his head to be a cross between a jack-o-lantern and a human skull. Kreeg runs to his window calling for Mr. Wilkins to help him, but is tackled by Sam. Kreeg gains the upper hand when he manages to fire his shotgun at Sam, seemingly killing it, in the process shooting off one of Sam's hands. As Kreeg dials 9-1-1, Sam re-attaches his hand and rises. Sam then attacks him again, stabbing at him with a large pumpkin sucker out of which he has taken a bite, rendering it sharp. Sam finds that the sucker has lodged itself into a piece of chocolate from which Kreeg had earlier taken a bite. Sam takes the sucker wedged into the chocolate and, having been given a treat, walks away. Meanwhile, pictures burning slowly in a nearby fireplace show a class photo of the masked children from the "School Bus Massacre" and the bus driver, who is revealed to be Kreeg.

Ending

Bandaged and bruised from his encounter with Sam, Kreeg answers his door to give candy to trick-or-treaters. While on his porch, he spots Sam walk over to Emma and Henry's house just after she blows out the jack-o'-lantern. Rhonda walks across the street in a trance and is almost hit by the laughing, human-form werewolf girls in their vehicle, on their way back from the surprise party. Young Billy Wilkins is sitting on his porch handing out candy and wearing a "Principal Wilkins" costume. Kreeg then walks back inside when there is another knock at the door. He opens the door to find the kids from the School Bus Massacre standing there with their bags outstretched, saying, "Trick 'r Treat". The ending is rendered as comic book pages showing the bus driver's fate at the hands of the undead children.