User blog comment:JoxFox2109/PE Proposal: Scar (2019)/@comment-39032584-20190731190524

I think we need to make more of a habit of checking to see who, if anyone, has already reserved the right to the discussion. If it was addressed with the administrators and deemed okay, then it's probably okay, but I still think anyone who wants to make an early proposal should ask the user who's reserved it for permission as well. I'm sure no one means any harm, but apart from it making the concept of reserving discussion rights kind of pointless, you have to consider that someone may have reserved it because they really wanted to be the one to make a proposal. I'm worried that at some point, someone's going to get really upset over this sort of incident.

Anyway, that aside, and since it seems to be okay, I'll add a yes for this version of Scar myself. Having seen it, The only thing comparatively better about him is that he actually goes on hunts with the hyenas personally, so he comes off as a little more competent as a ruler/king, but still incompetent enough that, like in the original, the Pride Lands become decimated, which affects everyone for the worse. And in conjunction with that, while he does come actually earn the loyalty of the hyenas more then in the original, he still only kept his word to them because he needed their help to secure his position, and obviously, he still tried to sell them out in the end. Overall, I'd say he's just as bad as the original, just in slightly different ways, like completely lacking his more humorous traits, giving him the aforementioned mentioned lust for Sarabi, and letting the lionesses starve first out of spite when she refuses to be his queen.