Thread:Jester of chaos/@comment-31330278-20170530021846/@comment-4708882-20170820103546

1. Agreed as it takes away part of the charms any of the original tales gave simply so it's easier to make a quick buck.

2. Yeah the Piper got carried away with his revenge and punished the wrong people especially when presumably it was more the leaders fault vs every citizen. Not necessarily as if they were young enough to reproduce again or had new young people enter the town in theory could survive plus depending on the tale up to three kids survive (a deaf kid, a blind kid and I think a slow kid (crutches or overweight hard to keep straight)). So it is possible the town survived but that might of been the Piper's plan.