User blog comment:ThatScrewyDuck/Aladdin 2019 PE Discussion/Proposal/@comment-39032584-20190610105711/@comment-25906608-20190610131122

Oh, well, good points he is darker than the original, but still, it's just the fan criticisms that might prove that he doesn't quite qualify, due to his lack of emotion and musical numbers and not having much of a menacing voice and charisma.