User blog:Jayden Jean-Baptiste/Injurin' Joe

Okay, I am aware that Injurin' Joe is one of those rare "we don't agree with TV Tropes" cases. To clarify, I'll admit right now that there are some TV Tropes labelled CMs I don't quite agree with (Dag comes to mind). But, having read the discussion on Joe for why he counted, some things need to be said. Also, I made a similar discussion on his talk page, but nobody responded.

First of all, the film Injurin' Joe appears in is in a different universe from the original version. With that in mind, this universe has a different heinous standard than the other versions. So, if we judge by this universe's standards, Joe does stand out and is evil enough.

But, secondly, and most importantly, Injurin' Joe does have a slightly lower bdycount than Injun Joe; but, as mentioned in his discussion, his crimes can be considered worse in a way. The people Injun Joe killed were criminals like himself; Injurin' Joe killed a deputy. So, with that in mind, that Injurin' Joe killed an innocent can be considered worse than killing a criminal. Also, unless I forgot something, Injun joe framed Mutt because he didn't want trouble with the authorities. Injurin' Joe is a known criminal and everyone is too scared to do anything against him, with few exceptions. So, there really was no reason to frame Mutt because everyone already was terrified of him. This just seemed like a pointless display of cruelty on Injurin' Joe's part. Couple with Mutt being not very bright, this pretty much makes things even worse.

I'll leave it at that, but I do think that Injurin' Joe qualifies in his own, separate universe from Injun Joe. If anyone wants to respond, I'll gladly discuss things further.