User blog comment:Rupert2/Should we erase the "'incomeptent villains can't be complete monsters' rule?/@comment-27006713-20170205221739/@comment-2175012-20170206000411

Sorry; commented on the wrong post. But otherwise, the villain in question needs to have awareness about what they're doing, or at the very least are competent. A villain who has schizophrenia, for instance, has a lesser chance at qualifying as they are unable to think rationally whenever they commit something heinous.