Thread:LucidPigeons/@comment-4708882-20150605000409/@comment-27560932-20150605125649

I believe you are correct. If Nightmare (in this case, the current named wielder of Soul Edge) has been driven to corruption because of Soul Edge's influence, he fails the "in control of his moral decisions" test. As for Soul Edge itself, the spirit inside Soul Edge itself is less of a character and more a force of corruption that, too, is Made of Evil and fails the independent morality. Neither characters truly apply for the Monster tag.