User blog comment:Mattia Garavini/Pure Evil proposal: Annihilus/@comment-30634893-20190920203619

This proposal highlights the exact problem that I've seen with comic book villain proposals before it, and perhaps most proposals in general: which is, in essence, only covering the most vile of a certain character's history, while leaving the voters to fill in the blanks. And it really is more blatant here than it is in others, because this only focuses on his role in Annihilation--which is perhaps his most famous apperance to date for sure, but far from his last. And singling out a chunk of a character's history absolutely does not fly in PE proposals, because the very idea is inheriently biased.

As such, I'm giving this a no. What Annihilus did in Annihilation was terrible, but, like Jester said, he's never been consistently at that same level of heinousness. And besides, even if we're going by Annihilation alone, Ultron in Annihilation: Conquest was still worse than him, since he also wanted to destroy all life, only he was more directly involved with the story, more sadistic, and did more to hurt the heroes of the story (brutally killing Moondragon right in front of her girlfriend Phyla-Vell, for example).