Thread:Panzysoldat/@comment-31330278-20190725214555/@comment-31330278-20190928125429

While I can understand you wish for a challenge, I must inform you that controversy in PE proposal is uncommon. Except for people like Eli Mills, either you have a consensus for yes, or a consensus for no. If it makes you feel any better, one day i'll propose Luther Thompson (Hook Man). A friend informed me that his proposal will invoke an interesting discussion. And equally important, one of my pen-mate on the "Scream" wiki agrees that Luther is pure evil. I know Beth is worse, both more evil and more repulsive, but Luther is vile enough as well. When taking in count the fact he created Jamal and his rivalry with Marcus by killing Deion, even without regarding the fact Luther is the only "Scream" killer so far who killed a child, his PTSD ain't holding water. Another reason he's pure evil is his motive to kill Deion. Even Beth wanted to achieve things in her petty way. Luther killed poor Deion because the child got unwittingly into his territory. Saying to Marcus "you have a lot of nerve to come here" means Luther knew exactly what he was doing. But for me, the worst thing Luther have done is making Marcus feel guilty for hating him. He made Marcus feeling guilty for hating the man who killed his brother. That's low even for a serial killer. No other killers have done that. Sidney and Emma were sad about killing their siblings, but never felt guilt. Unless you consider lack of sadism as a redeeming quality, Luther is irredeemable.