Thread:Nermal12/@comment-23995441-20131227055533/@comment-24600224-20131230182540

The difference between Courtney and Alejandro is that Alejandro delibertely intended for Bridgette and Leshawna to fall for him. Courtney never knew that Justin fell for her until Justin made it obvious that he did. That's certainly not Courtney's fault that Justin let his guard down willingly.

Also, I wasn't referring to that time that Cameron was annoying Courtney, but overall, Courtney was displeased with Cameron when she was on the heros team. Speaking of which, if it's unfair to label Cameron as a villain despite him being on the villains team, then it's unfair to label Courtney as a villain because she's on the villains team, and therefore the whole "X is a villain because he's on a certain team" is a flawed analogy. I'm glad to see that you saw how flawed that analogy is when I suggest that Cameron's a villain just because he's on the villains team. Therefore, you cannot say that Courtney is a villain because she got transfered on the villains team.

There are valid reasons for her to lie to herself considering her history with Gwen. She doesn't want to be vulnerable, humiliated, and hurt again so she refuses to even consider the notion of forgiving Gwen. It's a psychological defense for her to insist that she will not forgive Gwen, but the more and more she saw Gwen trying to apologize, the more and more defensive she gets and by consequence the more absurd her interrigations got. That's just how human psychology is and it reflects nothing of what Courtney would actually do to Gwen. The fact that Courtney pushed Justin off a cliff isn't her fault, because Courtney didn't set the rules up that way. Chris did, and he made it very clear the the person who would win immunity is the one who would win the dual fight. Moreover, Justin didn't seem to mind at all that he got eliminated by Courtney, so it's not something that should be brought up. Also, Courtney could have been smiling at something else entirely, there is no evidence that she was smiling at Cody. She made no comment or anything about it, afterall. You're assertion that Courtney put down her Gwen shield only after Gwen broke up with Duncan is a flawed assertion. She was surprised that Gwen "came back for her" in the confessional, which was when Gwen was still with Duncan. Moreover, Gwen confirmed that Courtney hadn't said anything about Duncan and Courtney mentioned that she's over Duncan anyway, so Duncan cannot be the wedge that placed Courtney and Gwen apart, although the history of him certainly did.

I would accept that Courtney is not a hero if you learn the difference between except and accept. :P Anyway, I would accept that Courtney is not a hero because she is not one. She is an anti-hero, which is distinct from a true hero. The difference between the villains befriending any of the heros is that the villains only did so to further their agenda. Courtney legitametly wanted to befriend and forgive Gwen. You make an assertion that many fans agree that Courtney is evil, but you seem to forgetting that the majority of people on the total drama wiki seem to think that Courtney's more of an anti-hero (or at the very least a fallen hero) than as a true villain. Moreover, you dodge the question. Why is it that many people still debate over whether Courtney's a hero or a villain? Because she's an anti-hero. You'd never find anyone who would debate whether Heather's good or bad, but you see a LOT of those debates on the total drama wiki concerning Courtney. Where's your evidence that many fans think Courtney's evil anyway?

Courtney didn't know if Zoey was going to die. Moreover, she gave Zoey a choice to save herself and Zoey still insisted that she didn't want her help. Courtney was simply giving her what she insisted on having. That's certainly not Courtney's fault. Also, the fact that Zoey didn't die despite Courtney not helping her kinda blows your theory that Courtney would rather have Zoey completely dead out of the water. Courtney knew that Zoey wouldn't get harmed because she is aware that Zoey has Mary-Sue powers.