Sylvie Garrett

Sylvie Garrett is the hidden main villainess from the 2017 Lifetime film, Mommy, I Didn't Do It, the sequel to 2013's The Wrong Woman.

She was played by Caroline Sunshine.

Sylvie Garrett is the best friend of the film's protagonist, Julie Plainview, but in actuality, Syivie harbored jealousy of Julie, feeling that she was inferior to her best friend. She also had a crush on their teacher, Gene Dutton, and attempted to begin a relationship with him, only to find out that the married teacher actually was in love with Julie--as Julie herself revealed to her mother, Ellen. Angry over being rejected, Sylvie plotted a murderous revenge, which began when she answered Gene's text to Julie telling her to meet him. After leaving Julie passed out during a night out with a pair of guys, Sylvie grabbed a knife from Julie's kitchen and donned an all-black disguise on her way to meeting Gene. Shortly after getting into the car, the evil Sylvie killed Gene, stabbing him multiple times in a fit of rage.

As a result of Sylvie's actions, Julie ended up arrested and charged with Gene's murder, as her prints were found in the car. Sylvie was revealed as the killer when Julie noticed a burned CD in his collection. The CD had mostly hip-hop songs, which Gene hated, meaning that whoever was in love with him had to have made it for him. Julie met Sylvie at the scene of Gene's murder with her discovery, and it was there that Sylvie confessed to the murder. She later took out the same knife and intended to kill Julie, only for Ellen (who also figured out Sylvie's villainous deed) to appear and rescue her daughter. The villainess attempted to kill Ellen, but was knocked out by Julie. Police arrived and arrested Sylvie for murder, clearing Julie.