Thread:LucidPigeons/@comment-27729149-20151204153148/@comment-26205772-20160109071459

The excuse in Roger's case is too vague to call it disqualifying, and Conroy's case doesn't even come close to justifying his actions as he lacks remorse either way. Roger at the least is a firm Complete Monster, although one could contest Conroy as he may not be as heinous as Paul, Michael, and Roger.

Paul's excuse... unfortunate as it is (especially given how he's so vile), yes, that disqualifies him from Monster status, regardless of the lack of empathy he may hold later in the future.