Thread:Jester of chaos/@comment-4048025-20151229161405/@comment-366087-20151229164923

Y'all know that section 6 of the Rules clearly defines the criteria and that everything mentioned in the OP here and on his page Fails against it.

Look, if you want to you can find faults with everyone enough to call them a "villain". Only three people are alleged to have ever been 100% perfect on this planet, and TWO of them still faltered. Don't like someone? List enough traits you don't agree with and poof, villain. Consistently speed? Unremorseful Villain. Play music too loud time after time? Inconsiderate villain. Don't replace toilet paper rolls? Magnificent Bastard villain.

6.1 says villains are *established* in their settings. That means the writers/producers of the show tell us what role characters play; not that we viewers decide based upon what we like or dislike about them (6.2—"just because something offends you does not make it evil / immoral"). And that being a Jerk (6.1) and an Antagonist is not the same as being Wicked/Evil (6.3).

Leonard continues to live with Sheldon. Does that make him a villain? Who would live with a villain but another villain? Penny and the rest are still friends with Sheldon. Are they villains? Who would be friends with villains but villains?

Howard was a horndog. Villain? Raj plays his divorced parents against each other. Villain? Amy recorded the reactions of a monkey and her boyfriend to various image stimuli, and played the friendships of Penny and Bernadette against each other. Villain?

No one is perfect. There are no situations involving 2 or more people that is 100% conflict-free. That's just life. One word: Marriage. Two more words: with Children. Conflicts galore. Doesn't make your spouse, children, siblings, parents villains. That's just people being people. Consider your own life. Never caused a conflict? Never almost got someone hurt or killed doing something stupid? Are you a villain?

None of this or what is on Sheldon's page measures up to the Rules.