Thread:LucidPigeons/@comment-2175012-20160323030814/@comment-2175012-20160409151144

Can consistency be bad? What I mean is, that you have villains like the Joker for example who's consistently portrayed as a CM, well, except for a few cases, so why would it be absurd to say that any version of Luthor could potentially count? Is it because it would "destroy" his character? I kind of noticed this when I proposed 1989!Erik; while I did get mostly upvotes regarding him, there was one downvote that really didn't give an explanation as to why the user had downvoted him. And then after that, they were acting hesitant as to thinking that any version of the Phantom could qualify. I understand that the Phantom of the Opera is consistently played as a sympathetic figure, but I don't understand why having this one deviation would send a few over the edge. Especially since this interpretation of the Phantom is vastly different from the other incarnations.

Also, does Bellwether have a mental illness? I would watch the film for myself, but I don't want to anymore.