Thread:LucidPigeons/@comment-27729149-20151204153148/@comment-27729149-20160109070113

Also, here's what I want to explain about Roger, Trevor, and Conroy.

People might be able to find legitimate reasons to disqualify them here are some examples:

With Roger it's been said that his mother drank and smoked while she was pregnant with him, and that his dad would constantly put drugs on his drinks and it would make him woozy, however despite that his mom and dad were not abusive they just didn't know better but you could tell they were trying to take care of him, but all of that backfired, while he is vile, it could be argued that it's the drugs that drove him insane.

Paul was initially a nice guy who truly cared about his family, but after a freak accident with his car, he ended up killing one of his kids by accident and was completly devastated, but what drove him to resort to cannibalism is the fact that the town kept calling him a psycho and an irresponsible jackass for doing that. Both him and his family were eventually driven out of town and they had to live in a cabin in the forest where Paul had nothing, eventually he got so desperate for food that he shot down a man driving in a car and then took him to the freezer, he keeps them alive to keep the meat fresh for his family to eat, his family never knew he was doing it and then when Michael finds out about this and tries to warn them it's too late because he found them hanged by Paul from a hook and ready to be prepared for cutting and cooking.

Conroy might have been drunk when said he wished he was sober when he killed his family, he was clearly seen drinking a bottle of beer before he gets shot to death.

These could be used to argue their complete monster status and it's possible that they don't even know what they are doing or saying, but it's undeniable they are complete a-holes. Remember the emphasis on maybe, it's never made clear.