Thread:Prime ShockWaveTX/@comment-27729149-20141226003540/@comment-24758512-20141228105432

I will answer all these questions, it may seem confusing at first, but if you watch the second season everything is explained in a very easy way.

First - Shion is a villain, but she can not be considered CM because she was infected with the Syndrome of Hinamizawa, and in her last moments when she fell from the building, she regretted what she did and she said that she would try again for all the mistakes her while cried.

Mion never was a villain, she just acted as a villain in the hallucinations caused by Syndrome of Hinamizawa, but in fact, she was a heroin the whole anime.

Satoko - (LOL NOPE)

Mika - She never was a villain, though she act strange and suspicious in sometimes, she never did anything wrong or evil. She only tried to kill Shion, but that was not a villain act but actually was a heroic act. In other words, she has never been and will never be a villain in any circumstances.

Keichii - I don't know about him, but I think he would qualify as an Anti hero because he had brutally killed the Hojo and Tame to protect Satoko, but he had good reasons.

Rena and Mion never tried injecting drug in Keiichi, that was all a hallucination, in fact they were trying to make a catch with Keiichi because he lost a game, in other words, they were just playing with him, while Keiichi was seeing something else more brutal in his hallucination.

Rena is definitely a villain, but she did all this because of Rina.

You should watch the season 2 to discover the truth, I hate to say Spoilers.