User blog comment:Magma MK-II/Characters that shouldn't be here, Part 3: Return of the Revenge/@comment-366087-20151230223311/@comment-366087-20151231232944

If something belongs on this wikia, it should be able to withstand any challenge.

Perhaps the rules could stand some tweaking?

I don't want any readers of my stories to tell me what the settings I establish are. No writer or producer would. We tell them what is being established. So if I was part of the writing staff on Dexter, or a Punisher comic or movie, and we say "this character is not the villain. He shoots/kills villains so he and society can sleep easier at night", we won't care for someone telling us we're wrong.

Dex and Pun are certainly Anti-heroes, but literarily speaking, not villains.

Now, say a story about Shego, who hates clones, was in a story where she finds out about a bunch of evil clones of herself and she goes around the world killing them. She is fully established as a villain in her canon setting so she'd still be a villain in this one.