Board Thread:Clean up Concerns/@comment-2175012-20171030003307/@comment-26277897-20180101031804

AustinDR wrote: Alright so with Afton, as far as I am concerned, the video game counterpart most likely counts towards this. For one, Afton had killed eleven children in total, he sets his son up as the fall guy by sending him to put his daughter "back together again" which results in him getting disemboweled and gutted by Ennard, and there are no lines of dialogue to suggest that he truly cared for his daughter in Pizzeria Simulator where he shows a genuine love of killing.

Though I am more sold on the novel version of Afton given that it lacks the ambiguity from the main games. I don't think William should be listed as Pure Evil yet. The only factor stopping him from qualifying as Pure Evil was his love for Elizabeth, which was implied in Sister Location​, due to stopping her from meeting Circus Baby and getting killed by her. With Pizzeria Simulator​'s release, due to the possible interpretation that all he wanted was her to continue his legacy, it's ambiguous as to whether William actually loved Elizabeth in the first place. I think there should be more content released first, and then see if he qualifies.