Thread:LostGod2000/@comment-23995441-20140407234101/@comment-1762629-20140407234740

I've been rather mixed on him. He certainly does inspire a lot of fear from every character on the show, and granted, his actions are horrid, but his actions are limited to bullying Eddy onscreen. This is what gets me mixed because he's never played for comedy (at least as seriously as the show can play him) and fulfills all the other criteria needed to be a Monster, but his abuse for Eddy is only shortly on screen before he's knocked out by a door and dragged away. However, what really settles it for me is the implications. Eddy's brother has been torturing Eddy all his life, and it's implied that he works at an amusement park so he can torture children. His motive? He's a cold-blooded sociopath who loves doing what he does. Torturing helpless children at that. That still may count for Offscreen Villainy, but since we're not following TV Tropes guidelines here (and I still stand by my opinion it's still horrid even if it's only implied) I guess he gets my vote for a CM, though his on-screen actions alone wouldn't qualify him.