Thread:Jester of chaos/@comment-4807601-20190724132525/@comment-25906608-20190729213553

Jester of chaos wrote: Ngh93, I may not care much about this in particular but here's the thing: you constantly do this and it's not simply "he doesn't count so add a quick opinion" it's what's actually shown: he sees a female of his species and rushes to see her and tried to win her over only to then find out it's a trap. This shows he's capable of love which PE's aren't shown doing. Whether this trivia is ultimately removed I'm less concerned with as much as your refusal to learn on edit warring to get your way. Besides we have allowed basic theories/speculations in trivia to be mentioned like "Its theorized ___ might return" and "While not outright stated many have theorized ___ might of formerly been ____ given their insight/skills in this field/organization".

B1bl1kal, I respect your insight but the main issue is two things: Minor mentions of theories aren't outright forbidden with even this instance not exactly a personal opinion but the scene does basically state Gutt could fall in love given he was immediately smitten with someone he thought was the same species vs outright mind control. The second and major recurring issue of Ngh93's edit warring simply to get his way instead of even trying to keep an open mind and discuss it with others. Actually, Jester I did take time to learn from my edit warring. In fact, as I thought it over, the Gutt and the siren scene could actually be interpreted a several different ways.

Maybe  Gutt was actually smitten or probably just dazed from Manny's blow. Gutt is usually very crafty, so Manny's defeating blow probably had something to do with the captain meeting his doom at the fins of the siren's. As for mind cntrol, that's another interpretation.

Due to the several different and debatable interpretations of Gutt's fate, maybe your theory's correct, maybe it isn't. It's just not as simple as it looks.