Thread:LucidPigeons/@comment-1396848-20150615165253/@comment-27560932-20150623183903

It's been talked about on TV Tropes' thread, it's been talked about here, my answer is still no. Sorry, but given your track record with this trope, I think you're letting candidates slip by far too easily; slightly beyond standard villainy does not mean "heinous enough to be a Monster." He's a nasty customer, but with the character trope of the CM you have to be really careful to make sure they're heinous enough for the bill. Too many people underestimate the heinous standard truly needed to become a CM, even given its definition as "worst of the worst."

Put up a poll if you want, but my vote is and always will be no for Scales (and Pigma for that matter, as the only two crimes he really has on his hands is betraying the old Star Fox team and selling out the galaxy to the Aparoids, which is, while nasty, not enough to make him a Monster; a single crossing of the MEH does not automatically make the crosser a CM).