User blog comment:Magma MK-II/Characters that shouldn't be here, Part 3: Return of the Revenge/@comment-366087-20151230223311/@comment-24977413-20151231200454

They certainly aren't a good measuring stick to use for whether another character is "good" or not. Point is Ruckus stays. No one likes him, he is an antagonist, he is malicious, and has arguably crossed the MEH.

You are taking these rules on villains too seriously. I can understand simple bullies not qualifying but characters that commit crimes (especially murder, torture or rape) deserve to be here and a lot of the examples I see you proposing are characters that have committed some pretty severe crimes.