User blog comment:Sppople/PE Proposal: Blackbeard (Pirates of the Caribbean)/@comment-31330278-20200217213008

I vote no. The standard is too high, with Beckett leading it. Davy Jones is tragic, yet he did worse compare to his resources. His multiple moments of declaring "there are no survivors" whenever he felt like killing whole crews are, pound for pound, worse than burning to death one specific oppositionist. Abusing mermaids was horrible, and holding his own daughter at gun point is despicable, but many POTC villains hurt people who're close to them and abused women (again, Davy was there before with similar resources). And more importantly, Blackbeard is actually scapegoat. Being dissolved by a powerful tide is more painful than it sounds. That's a fate only Beckett deserves.