Thread:BeholderofStuff/@comment-34055410-20190709170853/@comment-34055410-20190709183441

Oh, that's not really what I meant. If it's just any normal PE discussion, users who aren't familiar with the work can feel free to vote. What I was saying is that if the character is very debatable PE-wise, it just feels unsafe to let users who have no familiarity with the work vote. Take God as an example (in fact, his PE discussion is what gave me this idea in the first place). He’s debatable in that he was clearly meant to be written as a hero, but the author unintentionally made him a narcissist who tortured people for eternity for insanely petty reasons. Now, if everyone who voted on his EP read the Chick Tracts and knows who he is, more people would have voted “no”, but since almost half of the people who voted aren’t familiar with the character, they voted “easy yes” even though their votes/arguments would have been extremely different had they actually bothered to read the comics.