Thread:LucidPigeons/@comment-366087-20160214023142

Could you monitor Category:Villainesses for a while?

I've reverted edits twice now by different editors. If I revert the same again, It'll be a Revert War (3-of-same-type-in-a-row is the definition of a revert war), and of course I don't wish to feed into that.

Again, basically what needs to be asked of a Category being *added to* a category is "is everything defined in this addition *also* defined by what it is being added to?"

If "No", then it should not be added.

In this case of adding Category:Villains by Type, not ALL Villains by Type are Villainesses. So answer is "no" and it should not be added. 