Thread:DarkUnknownWarrior/@comment-1682045-20170908205508/@comment-1705775-20170908212329

alright, here's the deal - some of the tags you've used are also wrong..

Incoherent is for insanely hard to read text and/or gibberish.. like if someone wrote an article in extremely broken english or started going on a weird rant about a subject no one could understand unless they were aware of the show / franchise (like techno-babble or similar).. not simply for "Clean Up" or "Rewrite".

"Stub" is for short articles - use it more.. because you've often used "One-Line" on articles that are far from One-Line, that means users have worked hard to make an article and instead of giving them a chance to improve you've slapped "One-Line" on it and tagged it for deletion.

not very fair, is it?

if an article is in need of expanding use "Stub" more than "One-Line" and do not use Incoherent unless the article is truly horrendous.