2019 easy. You ask me, he was the VICTIM of that story.

Indeed, the same can’t be said for TKJ. Also, it was always coming down like thunder on Arthur from Day 1, whereas for TKJ Joker, it was that 1 bad day.

2019 Joker

I mean KJ Joker is tragic but there's the actions to consider. Who did Arthur even hurt directly? 5 a**holes and the woman responsible for his whole life being sideways. What had Batman, Barbara & Gordon done to KJ Joker?

2019 Joker was probably the most sympathetic Joker I’ve seen (aside from Flashpoint Joker, I guess).

Again though, what did Alfred ever do?