Hmm, Afton may be bad obviously, but he isn't considered "one of the worst" compared with the 3 the two mean....

Bro william is not that evil compared to other PEs how can u not see that

@I am Mimic1 This trio are the most infamous literary villains. That's why they're commonly discussed at the same time. Throwing someone else is kinda... odd?

All three are beyond redemption, so here are my thoughts on the appropriate punishments:

Qu: Because the Qu are a hivemind, each individual bug can be given a separate form of torture or mutilation, like they did to their victims, and it would be felt amongst all of them. Do this to all of them until all but one is dead. Keep that one alive (somehow), possibly on cryo.

Holden: Honestly, I think as awful as the Judge is, his character works best when he gets away with all his crimes. Really sells the idea of him being this machiavellian evil. Besides, we never see the Judge "lose", pre se, so knowing what exactly would hurt him most isn't really possible. So, as awful as he is, I can't think of a punishment that suits him, based on the way his character is written.

AM: The worst of the worst, there isn't a punishment worthy for all AM's done. Considering he gave Ted one of the worst fates worse than death in all of fiction, it's hard to think of something worse than that. The best punishment for AM would be to make him powerless, and force him to endure the tortures he inflicted onto others.

Honestly, in my opinion, the most satisfying punishments for villains is doing to them what they did to their victims.

Hmm for the judge Llama, maybe put him in the theraprism where Bill Cipher is, or trap him in Afton's nightmare, which you think is a good punishment for the judge though?

@Accounty the Sequel Ahhhh I see you mean book villains well I mean William is a book villain

@Hazbinhotelanddcfan He's a rapist bro (well at least his VR replica is) not only that but he is known to torture his victims before killing them he's forced innocent kids to have a fate worse than death be trapped inside of an metal prison he's evil completely awful he has zero remorse for his actions not even his own family is safe from his terror I think that you're not thinking about this from my point of view because here's what makes William so evil he has NO reason to do what he does at least AM has somewhat of a reason to do what he does sure he may not have a good reason but it's a reason William has NO reason that's what makes him so evil he may have a tragic past (at least it's implied from Henry's speech) but still it's not enough of a reason to justify anything he's done and as far as we know William may not even have a tragic past and could just be an asshole who tortures kids for fun

What???

Bro what ??? since when was he a rapist its not even listed on one of his crimes

And also many PEs do what they do for fun william isnt different

@I am Mimic1 No one is saying William Afton is not evil, but he just isn't as evil as The Judge, AM, and the Qu. I don't understand why you are still fighting for this. The Qu and AM also put their victims in WAY WORSE fates worse than death. Unlike your speculation that Afton is a rapist, Holden actually is, and does it more people than Afton has ever killed. Plus, all three of the unholy trinity have WAY more kills than Afton. There is literally not a single category on the villainous spectrum in which Afton is more evil than Holden, AM, or the Qu.