I meannnnnnn it depends because some speculate that William from the games is both Fazbear Fright and the og version so.......... It really depends on you view it now if you were to use only a single version of William like not including books then I mean....... Yeah Ig they don't compare to these 3 villains however if it helps I suppose I'll just use the game version (unless we should include Fazbear Frights with this debate)

@I am Mimic1 Okay, I'm glad we can clear that up. The OG ScottGames Afton is likely the most evil version, which is a different version than the Fazbear Frights Springtrap, so you can't say that Afton is a rapist in your argument if you are trying to prove that that the OG William is more evil.

Now, in fairness to something that was said, I'm not going to try and say that every other PE villain is more evil than Afton. Afton does stand out, in my opinion, as one of the most evil indie horror villains. However, in comparison to figures like the unholy trinity here, he just isn't as evil.

Since you've agreed that AM and Qu are both more evil, I will just try and show you Holden's stats to convince you he is more evil:

• Holden has more confirmed kills, as he spends the novel assisting the Glanton Gang in genocide, and having over a hundred individual kills.

• Holden is a rapist and pedo, as mentioned before.

• Holden tortures people more than Afton, as he scalps some of his victims alive, crushes skulls with his bare hands, burns people alive, and organizes riots to kill innocent people out of boredom.

• While it is true Holden never directly gives anyone a fate worse than death like Afton did, Holden does leave irreparable scars on the victims he rapes, as they are mainly children.

I think it's a tie for William and Holden at least with me because they are both sadistic bastards who only think about themselves also if that's the case then should we have a page for Golden Freddy's FF version on the wiki?

Bro your not proving your point in this argument william doesnt even compare to other PE villains let alone the holy trinity

So you're saying that Abigail Williams is more evil than William?

Who tf is that

I can see that you aren't paying attention to what I'm saying to you because if you did you'd know also there's no need for all the swearing if you're going to make an argument then hear the other persons points before imputing your thoughts

Just, for the record, while I don't think Afton is more evil than this unholy trinity, I do agree that Afton is more evil than Abigail Williams, and he does stand out compared to other PEs. I'd say he's one of the more evil indie horror game Pure Evils.

Afton may be more likely a candidate for the most evil indie game villain.

@Piccolo Machiavelli Thank you for reading my points and at least understanding what I'm saying rather than just saying stuff also once again should we make a page for Golden Freddy's FF? Because I included FF Afton with mine mainly because of the fact that it's possible he could be the game version