Villains Wiki

Hi. This is Thesecret1070. I am an admin of this site. Edit as much as you wish, but one little thing... If you are going to edit a lot, then make yourself a user and login. Other than that, enjoy Villains Wiki!!!


Villains Wiki
This article's content is marked as Mature
The page Mature contains mature content that may include coarse language, sexual references, and/or graphic violent images which may be disturbing to some. Mature pages are recommended for those who are 18 years of age and older.

If you are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are free to view this page. Otherwise, you should close this page and view another page.

I enjoy society... flaws and all. You people venerate savagery... and you will die... savagely. All of you.
~ Andrew Milton to Arthur Morgan.
You fools weren't listening to me, were you? I showed mercy... You mistook it for weakness. Now I will show strength... and you may mistake it for brutality. There is no escape for any of you. I shall hunt you to the ends of the earth... and the end of time. I've killed your friends... and I've enjoyed killing them... and now I'm gonna kill each and every one of you!
~ Agent Milton and his men facing the Van der Linde gang.

Andrew Milton is a major antagonist in the Red Dead Redemption duology serving as one of the two secondary antagonists alongside Colm O'Driscoll, of the 2018 video game Red Dead Redemption II and as a posthumous antagonist in Red Dead Redemption. He is an agent in the Pinkerton National Detective Agency, and partner of Edgar Ross. He is also Dutch van der Linde's arch-nemesis.

He was voiced by John Hickok in motion capture.


Agent Milton is a ruthless man who is determined in catching and killing the Van der Linde gang and ending the era of the wild west. While appearing somewhat gentlemanly and courteous, he was willing to mercilessly kill Hosea Matthews after the latter surrendered to him and his men peacefully. He was also willing to have his men open fire on the gang in a derelict house with women and a child inside. It is also indicated that other Pinkerton Agents dislike him as one stated he'd like to "find a poisonous snake for him". He also has a subtle sadistic side, as he laughed while almost killing a sick Arthur Morgan.

Despite his ruthlessness, Milton is willing to negotiate with the enemy, as he promised Arthur that he wouldn't be hanged if he turned Dutch over. He also promised to let the gang live if Dutch surrendered and the rest of them left and lived normal lives. Aside from this, Milton does have the redeeming quality of wanting to bring about a peaceful society and end the murder and chaos of his time.


In 1899, Milton and his partner Edgar Ross were hired by Leviticus Cornwall to hunt down and kill Dutch van der Linde. Both agents eventually find Arthur Morgan fishing with little Jack Marston at a lake near Horseshoe Overlook.

Later, Milton and Ross find Dutch and his gang at their camp in Clemens Cove and give him and ultimatum to surrender or they will kill everyone.

During a robbery in Saint Denis, Milton shows up with a bunch of agents, and killing both Hosea Matthews and Lenny Summers, as well as capturing John Marston. The unfortunate turn of events forces Dutch and his gang to stowaway on a boat before eventually returning to the United States.


Eventually, he captures Abigail Roberts and hold her at Van Horn Trading Post until a boat arrives to pick her up. However, Arthur and Sadie Adler come to her rescue before the latter was too captured, forcing Arthur to come to her aid.

After being confronted by a mortally sick Arthur, Milton tells him that Micah Bell has been working for him shortly after coming back from Guarma before the two men engage in a battle. Just when Milton had the upper hand on Arthur (mainly due to Arthur losing strength to his sickness), he was suddenly shot in the side of his head by Abigail, killing him instantly.


Edgar Ross avenges both Andrew Milton's and Micah Bell's deaths when he finally betrayed and later killed John Marston in the original game, although Jack Marston kills Ross as revenge for John's death.


           Official Red Dead logo.png Villains

Red Dead Revolver
Bad Bessie | Bloody Tom | Captain Bufias | Colonel Daren | General Diego | Governor Griffon | Grizzly | Holstein Hal | Longhorn Luke | Mr. N. Black | Pig Josh | Professor Perry | Sam | Smitty | Ugly Chris Bailey | The Ugly Gang | Black Gang | Jesse Lynch

Red Dead Redemption
Abraham Reyes | Agustin Allende | Archer Fordham | Williamson Gang | Bill Williamson | Dutch's 1911 Gang | Dutch van der Linde | Edgar Ross | Espinoza | Javier Escuella | John Marston | Mexican Army | Norman Deek | Randall Forrester | Seth Briars | Vincente De Santa | Mario Alcalde | Granville Berry | Bureau of Investigation | Banditos | Bollard Twins Gang | Walton's Gang | Reyes' Rebels

Read Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare
Undead (Abraham Reyes, Mordecai Robbard & Vincente De Santa) | Seth Briars | John Marston | Granville Berry | Sasquatch Hunter

Red Dead Redemption II
Van der Linde gang
Dutch van der Linde| Arthur Morgan | John Marston | Cleet and Joe | Leopold Strauss | Micah Bell | Hosea Matthews | Josiah Trelawny | Bill Williamson | Javier Escuella | Charles Smith | Lenny Summers | Karen Jones | Sean MacGuire | Sadie Adler | Susan Grimshaw

Chapter 1: Colter
Colm O'Driscoll | O'Driscoll Boys

Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook
Leviticus Cornwall | Andrew Milton | O'Driscoll Boys

Chapter 3: Clemens Point
Catherine Braithwaite | O'Driscoll Boys | Braithwaite Family | Lemoyne Raiders | Tavish Gray | Gray Family | Leigh Gray

Chapter 4: Saint Denis
Angelo Bronte | Angelo Bronte's Mob

Chapter 5: Guarma
Alberto Fusar | Cuban Military | Levi Simon

Chapter 6: Beaver Hollow
Colonel Henry Favours | United States Army | Leviticus Cornwall | Andrew Milton | Murfree Brood | O'Driscoll Boys | Pinkertons

Epilogue Part 1: Pronghorn Ranch
Laramie Gang Leader | Laramie Gang | Mr. Abel

Epilogue Part 2: Beecher's Hope
Micah Bell | Skinner Brothers | Micah's gang | Cleet and Joe

Bray and Tammy Aberdeen | Edmund Lowry Jr. | Elias Green | General Quincy T Harris | Ku Klux Klan | Curtis Malloy | Lindsey Wofford | Night Folk | Otis Skinner | Saint Denis Urchins | Saint Denis Vampire | Jim "Boy" Calloway | Flaco Hernández | Emmet Granger | Billy Midnight | Black Belle | Ramon Cortez | Esteban Cortez | Benedict Allbright | Ellie Anne Swan | Joshua Brown | Jeremiah Compson | Camille de Millemont | Anthony Foreman | Nathan Kirk | Mark Johnson | Bart Cavanaugh | Medicine Man | Herman Zizendorf | Shane Finley | Sonny

Red Dead Online
Free Roam
Red Dead Online Protagonists | JB Cripps | James Langton | Old Man Jones
Bounty Hunter
Carmela "La Muneca" Montez | The Wolf Man | Sergio Vincenza | Philip Carlier | Owlhoot Family | Yukon Nik Borodin | Borodin's Gang | Red Ben Clempson | Red Ben Gang | Etta Doyle | Etta's Gang | Barbarella Alcazar | Seventh Generation | Virgil "The Shepherd" Edwards | Gene "Beau" Finley | Tobin Winfield | Cecil C. Tucker
A Land of Opprtunities
Amos Lancing | Teddy Brown | Teddy Brown's Boys | Jorge Montez | Alfredo Montez | Del Lobo Gang | Jeremiah Shaw | Grace Lancing
A Life of 'Shine
Reid Hixon | Danny Lee Caton