Faux Affably Evil is a term referring to villains who, at a glance, are similar to those who are the Affably Evil type, but with a lack of sincerity to their affable and sympathetic nature. Such villains are rarely, if ever wrathful or patronizing in front of the heroes, but they do not actually show any empathy towards others; as such, they are sounding polite but not acting it which causes their villainy to stand out more rather than less.

In some works, Faux Affably Evil villains break the Fourth Wall and reveal their true nature to the audience, while pretending to be nice in front of the protagonists. Arrogant villains who give a sarcastic apology to their foes also fall under this category. However, the characters of the story and audience alike might not be aware of the Faux Affably Evil villain's true colors until they reveal them.

Despite their lack of sincerity, some of these villains can actually be remorseful due to the fact that sometimes the hero can reach them in heart (usually done with Pure Goods). They also can be either insecure, redeemable or both; Marina Arusu is a good example.

On the other hand, many of them can be Pure Evil, since they can use "flattery" and "elegant" demeanors to get whatever they want and achieve their goals; Emperor Palpatine, Lord Voldemort, Scar, Jenner, Joker, Judge Claude Frollo, Frieza, Ego, Kefka Palazzo, Dimentio, Bill Cipher, Pennywise, Makuta Teridax and Isaac Ray Peram Westcott are very good examples of this.