Villains Wiki
Villains Wiki
This article's content is marked as Mature
The page Mature contains mature content that may include coarse language, sexual references, and/or graphic violent images which may be disturbing to some. Mature pages are recommended for those who are 18 years of age and older.

If you are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are free to view this page. Otherwise, you should close this page and view another page.

Willing or not, Jake always has a mate.
~ McNare bragging about his killings.

Frank McNare, also known as Body By Jake and BBJ, is the main antagonist of the Law & Order: Criminal Intent episode "Shibboleth". He is a serial killer who has murdered several women over twenty years, and resurfaces after several years of inactivity. He is loosely based on Dennis Rader, a serial killer also known as the "BTK Killer".

He was portrayed by the late Kevin Conway, who also portrayed Conrad Straker in The Funhouse.


Early Life

McNare is a sexual sadist who derives pleasure from torturing and murdering women. His signature is to tie up his victim behind her back with a blue and white rope, binding her neck and leg so that she would choke to death if she relaxed her leg muscles. While he does not sexually assault his victims, he masturbates as he watches them struggle and, eventually, die. He killed his first known victim in 1977, and killed five more over the next five years. The media dubbed him "Body By Jake" or "BBJ" after he killed an aerobics instructor.

McNare stopped killing in 1982 upon marrying his second wife, a masochist who willingly participated in his sadistic sexual fantasies. He eventually got a job with New York City's Transit Authority, and spent his days having sadistic sexual fantasies about female passengers. When his wife was diagnosed with breast cancer, she could no longer fulfill his sadistic desires, so he began stalking women; when she died, he began killing again.

Keith Durbin, McNare's son by his first wife, found a picture of his father's first victim, bound and gagged, in McNare's glove compartment when he was seven years old. The image was profoundly traumatic for Keith, and he re-enacted it by dressing his teddy bear in his mother's underwear and tying a blue string around its leg. Upon hitting puberty at thirteen, Keith discovered that he was sexually aroused by the image of a woman bound and gagged, and feared that he would become like his father, especially after McNare told him that he cannot run away from being his "flesh and blood".


McNare murders a woman and calls 911 as she is choking so the operator can listen to her die. He then sends taunting letters to the police and the media demanding to be recognized. Detectives Robert Goren and Alexandra Eames realize that "Body By Jake" has begun killing again, and they try to provoke him into making a mistake by telling the press that he kills because he is sexually inadequate. Sure enough, McNare's ego is so wounded that he attempts to assert his power by killing a woman he has been stalking for weeks, but luckily she is held up at work and does not return home at her usual time. Enraged, McNare leaves her underwear and a noose on her floor, along with an angry poem declaring, "Willing or not, Jake always has a mate.".

Goren and Eames' investigation leads them to the now-adult Keith, who had been arrested years earlier for binding and gagging his girlfriend in a sex game gone wrong. Keith, who has spent years repressing his sexual desires for fear of becoming a murderer, pleads innocence, but is nevertheless indicted for the BBJ murders because of circumstantial evidence tying him to the victims. Goren has doubts, however, noting that Keith lacks the arrogance BBJ exhibits in his letters.

Goren and Eames look further into the case, theorizing that BBJ had most likely killed far more women than he was given credit for. They uncover evidence linking him to an unsolved murder in 1977, as well as DNA that proves that the killer is related to Keith. They question McNare, who has not seen Keith since 1983, and Goren sees that he is a cruel, egotistical bully, much like the BBJ of the letters. Goren takes DNA from McNare, which sends the killer into a panic until he learns that his son has been indicted.

Goren and Eames bring McNare in to their station house under the pretense of asking for information about Keith. McNare tries to implicate Keith in the murders, coldly dismissing his son as a "panty-waist" and a "pervert". He even says that he doubts Keith is his biological son. Unbeknownst to him, Goren has brought Keith in to see what kind of person McNare really is, and tells him that he is nothing like his father. Keith breaks down and admits that he saw the photo of the murdered women in McNare's car, which gives Goren and Eames the proof they need to arrest McNare. As McNare is led away, he calls Keith "no son of mine", and Eames remarks that this was the nicest thing he could have said to Keith.

External Links


           Law & Order Logo.png Villains

Law & Order
Albert Lawrence Cheney | April Troost | Lorraine Dillon | Arthur Pruitt | Arthur Tunney | Dawn Sterling | Willard Tappen | Donald Shalvoy | Rita Shalvoy | Edward Auster | Laura Di Biasi | Mitch Carroll | Melanie Cullen | Dena Carter | Phillip Swann | Diana Hawthorne | Thad Messimer | Dr. Diane Meade | Eileen Willick | Emma Kim | Frances Houston | Jenny Brandt | Ned Lasky | Gayle Janaway | Joseph Krolinsky | Jacob Lowenstein | Joyce Pollock | Julia Veloso | Katherine Waxman | Leon Vorgitch | Liann Crosby | Mark Bruner | Molly Preston | Samantha Weaver | Simon Brooks | Stephanie Harker |

Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
Alana Gonzalez | Alec Bernardi | Alexa Pearson | Alexander Strizhov | Amelia Chase | Andre Bushido | Anna Mill | Anya Ragova | April Troost | Lorraine Dillon | Arthur Pruitt | Ash Gordon | Austin Bates | Billy Tripley | Brent Latimer | Bridget "Birdie" Sulloway | Carlo Parisi | Carl Vucelik | Chet Sulloway | Chris Carnasis | Christine Hartwell | Church of Wisdom and Sight | Dale Stuckey | Delia Wilson | Bart Ganzel | Dana Lewis | Daniel Varney | Darius Parker | Darryl Kern | Deacon Brinn | Dean Reynolds | Deborah Latrell | Denise Cormier | Denise Pikering | Dennis Caufield | Dr. Carl Rudnick | Dr. Nicole Keller | Edgar Noone | Edward Crandall | Elaine Frye Cavanaugh | Emily McCooper | Emma Spevak | Eric Byers | Eric Lutz | Eric Plummer | Erik Weber | Eugene Hoff | Frank Martin | Gary Rosten | Gideon Hutton | Gloria Montero | Gordon Rickett | Grace Rinato | Graham Winger | Harry Waters | Harvey Denis | Heather Parcell | Heather Riggs | Henry Mesner | Holden March | Ingrid Block | Orville Underwood | Jaina Jansen | Jake Berlin | Jake O'Hara | Jake the Kidnapper | Jaleel Amir | Jamie Huntington | Jason Mayberry | Grace Mayberry | Jimmy G. | Jiya Alexander | Joe Blaine | John Conway | John Fenwick | Johnny D. | Joseph Serumaga | Judge Hilda Marsden | K.O.B.S | Katie Cavanaugh | Kenneth Cleary | Kevin O'Donnell | Larry Moore | Laurel Linwood | Lauren Cooper | Lawrence Holt | Liam Connors | Linnie Malcolm | Lloyd Andrews | Louise Durning | Lowell Harris | Lucas Biggs | Luke Mitchell | Maggie Peterson | Malcolm Hunt | Mark Foster | Mark Ocurro | Marta Stevens | Martin Schultz | Matthew Brodus | Max Matarazzo | Merritt Rook | Michelle Osborne | Miguel Lopez | Mike D. | Miriam Penner | Missy Kurtz | Neil Alexander | Nikki Hallander | Noah Sibert | Orlando McTeer | Pam Adler | Paula Foster | Peggy Bernardi | Perry Moncaldo | Peter Harrison | Peter Ridley | Phoebe Bernap | Professor Rousseau | Ray Gunther | Richard Finley | Richard White | Ricky Blaine | Riley Couger | Riley Porter | Rob Miller | Robert Morten | Robert Sidarsky | Roy Barnett | Ryan Quinn | Sadie Parker | Sal Avelino | Saleh Amir | Sam Conway | Scott Dayton | Scott Heston | Sean Kelley | Sean Webster | Sheila Porter | Sheldon Kerrick | Stefan Tanzic | Teddy Winnock | Terri Banes | Tony Kelly | Victor Paul Gitano | Walter Burlock | William Lewis |

Law & Order: Criminal Intent
Christine Mayfield | Christine Wilkes | Dennis Griscom | Danielle McCaskin | Dr. Katrina Pynchon | Mark Ford Brady | Elise Garrett | Harry Rowan, Sr. | Evan Chapel | Ella Miyazaki | Jo Gage | John Tagman | Edwin Lindgard | Dani Hasni | Paul Devildes | Trudy Pomeranski | Declan Gage | Gerry Rankin | Charles Webb | Johnny Feist | Dede McCann | Barry Freeburg | Karl Atwood | Jack Crawley | James Bennett | Kathy Jarrow | Nicole Wallace | Frank McNare | Didier Foucault | Axel Kaspers | Bernard Fremont | Conroy "Connie" Smith | Tammy Mills

Law & Order: LA
Monica Jarrow | Valerie Roberts

Law & Order: Organized Crime
Diego Morales | Richard Wheatley

Dr. Greg Yates |