This Villain was proposed and approved by Villains Wiki's Pure Evil Proposals Thread. Any act of removing this villain from the category without a Removal Proposal shall be considered vandalism (or a futile "heroic" attempt of redemption) and the user will have high chances of being terminated blocked. You cannot make said Removal Proposal without permission from an admin first.
Additional Notice: This template is meant for admin maintenance only. Users who misuse the template will be blocked for a week minimum.

This article's content is marked as Mature
The page Mature contains mature content that may include coarse language, sexual references, and/or graphic violent images which may be disturbing to some. Mature pages are recommended for those who are 18 years of age and older.

If you are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are free to view this page. Otherwise, you should close this page and view another page.

Go on home to your police friends and leave me here in my local paradise. Get thee beyond me, Satan.
~ Michael Garfield to Poirot, revealing his true nature.

Michael Garfield is the main antagonist of Hallowe'en Party, a 1969 detective novel written Agatha Christie, which is one of her later books of Hercule Poroit series, as well as its 2010 TV episode adaptation of Agatha Christie's Poirot.

He was introduced as a talented gardener of Mrs. Louise Llewellyn-Smythe, but had an affair with Mrs. Rowena Drake, and they planned a murder to take the rich old woman's legacy, ending up killing at least three people (six in the TV series).

In Agatha Christie's Poirot, he was portrayed by Julian Rhind-Tutt, who also portrayed Dr. Arthur Calgary in Agatha Christie's Marple.

TV show Biography


Little is known about Micheal Garfield's early life. He was a man who was obsessed with pretty things. He once fall in love with Judith Butler and they have a daughter named Miranda. However, Micheal was too obsessed with beauty and Judith considered him as a man with madness and cruelty. She left him without telling him about her pregancy, making Miranda's last name "Butler" instead of "Garfield". She later came to Woodleigh Common and stayed there.

Years later, while Judith telling everyone about a lie of her "pilot husband" died in an car accident, Micheal arrived in Woodleigh Common and became the gardener of the rich widow, Mrs. Louise Llewellyn-Smythe. He made Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe's garden a beautiful scenery. Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe's niece, Rowena Drake, who had a seriously disabled husband Hugo, falled in love with Micheal and planned to marry him. Micheal followed her plan (and he fooled her) in order to gain money, so he killed Mr. Drake in a manipulated car "accident", and then they planned to kill the sickly Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe in order to get her heritage.

However, Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe's new maid, Olga Seminoff, know the love affair and she reminded her hostess. Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe changed her codicil in rage. She cut off her tie with the House of Drake and left her money, house and garden to Olga for she was an honest and genuine servant. One of Drake Family's solicitors, Leslie Ferrier, who once imprisoned for forgery but later released after helped by his later employer Mr. Fullerton, told Mrs. Drake about Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe's change of mind. Ferrier faked a clumsy "codicil" and concealed the real one, framing Olga for faking her mistress' will.

Later, Mrs. Drake and Micheal Garfield poisoned Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe and framing Olga as a gold digger and liar. Olga was furious and accused Mrs. Drake's evil deeds in her house, but was stabbed to death. Micheal buried Olga's corpse in Drake Family's garden. However, a ten-year-old Miranda Butler witnessed what Micheal did. Micheal guessed out that Miranda witness this and lied to her that the murder is a "sacrifice", and said "Sacrifices are necessary." Miranda thought this was a sacrifice and an accident, so she never told everyone except Joyce Reynolds, her best friend, without telling her the murderer is Micheal.

After Olga's death, Micheal finds Leslie Ferrier. He pretended to be grateful about what Ferrier had done and gave him the rewarding money. However, when Ferrier about to get away, Micheal stabbed him to death in order to shut him up, and he faked the murder as a killing for hatred. Now, he and Mrs. Drake thought they might be safe.

Hallowe'en Party

Two years later, in 1938, Micheal Garfield went to Athens, the capital of Greece. Meanwhile, in a Halloween party of Drake Family, Joyce Reynolds boasted about she witnessed a murder (which represented the murder of Olga Seminoff two years ago). Rowena Drake was horrified and she secretly drowned Joyce in an apple bobbing tub filled with water.

When Hercule Poroit on his way to Woodleigh Common in order to investigate Joyce's murder, he met Micheal Garfield. Poroit knew from Micheal's lips that Micheal is not the murderer of Joyce. After suggesting Poroit to visit Mrs. Goodbody, Micheal met Rowena Drake and was told of Joyce's words. Later, Micheal drowned Joyce's brother Leopold for he witnessed his sister's death and blackmailed Mrs. Drake.

However, Michael guessed that Joyce was lying, and he called Miranda and lured her in Drake Family's garden, but his attempting murder was stopped by Poirot, Ariadne Oliver, Judith Butler and Inspector Timothy Raglan. Inspector Raglan arrested Micheal and sent him in the house of Drake's family. After Poroit revealed that Judith was Micheal's real lover, Micheal admitted his crime and revealed all he wanted was money and the garden. He even later planned to buy a Greek island, build a garden and start afresh. He was took away by Inspector Raglan minutes later, with a crying Mrs. Drake.

Book Biography

In the original Hallowe'en Party novel by Agatha Christie, the description of Michael Garfield is much more shallow and ambiguous. In the original novel, he is shown to be the same egotist like his TV series version, even being compared to The Devil/Lucifer and Narcissus by Poirot himself. However, in the novels, it is not explained whether Michael was fully involved in the deaths of either Mr. Drake or Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe, since neither of their deaths are explained beyond car accident and dying of sickness, respectively.

In the original version, Michael Garfield was actually the lover of Olga Seminoff, who was in a unrequited romance with him, around the same time he and Rowena Drake had a love affair. However, while being aware of Olga's feeling for him, Michael merely saw Olga as his scapegoat and murdered her when she was accused of forgery. He and Mrs. Drake hid Olga's body in the garden, specifically inside a dried well, but was witnessed by Miranda. Years later, Miranda overheard their conversation about buying a Greek island and recognized them as the murderers.

Unlike the TV series, in the novels, it was implied that Michael truly had fathering feeling towards Miranda, to the point of drawing a sketch of her in order to keep herself in mind. However, this could be interpreted into another perverted action since he always tried to kill her for witnessing the death of Olga.

By the end of novel, when his plans was stopped by Poirot, Michael committed suicide by drinking the poison he reserved for himself and Miranda, rather than facing justice and confessing his motive like that in the TV adaptation.


TV Series

Now, you and I will drink to the past and future, and... Ahh... to beauty. (- Miranda: That will be nice. What does it taste of?) It'll taste of whatever you want it to. It's magical, you see. It's quite magical. You remember what I said, Miranda, about returning to nature? Look at the Moon... and you will be there soon. Up there, amongst the cold stars... Immortal.
~ Michael Garfield convincing Miranda to poison herself (TV series).
Don't make a fuss, you silly creature. It's... so undignified. It's true. I did it all for the money - Of course, I did... and... for the garden. Actually, I was thinkining about buying a little Greek island, start afresh... (- Mrs. Rowena Drake: NOOOOOO! NOOOOOOOOO!) I just like pretty things, you see. it's that so wrong? (- Mrs. Drake: NO!) And one must have money to get pretty things. I was very fond of you, Judith. Once. But even you're losing your looks now. (- Poirot: *shocked* Hmm?) It is an awful shame, do you not think, Monsieur, that we all must wither and die?
~ Michael revealing his true nature to Mrs. Drake and Poirot (TV series).


  • Body counts:
    • 4+ (novel)
    • 6+ (Agatha Christie's Poirot)


  • Hugo Drake
  • Leslie Ferrier (also in the novel)
  • Leopold Reynolds (also in the novel)


  • Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe
  • Olga Seminoff (also in the novel)
  • Joyce Reynolds (also in the novel)


  • Miranda Butler (also in the nove; survivedl)


  • Beatrice White: In fact suicide.



  • Whilst Rowena Drake is the killer of Joyce Reynolds, she is actually the novel's secondary antagonist. Garfield should be considered as the main antagonist of Hallowe'en Party because he had much bigger plans and was manipulating Mrs. Drake's love towards him all along, only to serve his own biddings.
  • Michael Garfield is one of the most prolific killer in Agatha Christie's Poirot, who killed 5 people in the TV series with Rowena Drake, plus having an indirect role in Joyce Reynolds and attempting to murder Miranda Butler (6 body counts, 1 attempted; 7 in all).
    • It is one of the highest confirmed body counts ever recorded in an original work by Agatha Christie and its adaptations. It lost to Justice Lawrence John Wargrave from And Then There Were None, who directly murdered 8 people, before committing suicide to fake his innocence (9 in all), although his plan caused all 10 major characters in the story (including himself) died in process.
  • Five years before Hallowe'en Party aired its TV adaptation, Julian Rhind-Tutt, who is Michael Garfield's actor, portrayed Dr. Arthur Calgary in the 2007 TV adaptation of Ordeal by Innocence. The said adpatation serves as an episode in the Series 3 of Agatha Christie's Marple.
  • The name of Michael is possibly an irony with Biblical reference, since Poirot compares Michael Garfield as Satan/Lucifer after seeing his dark and twisted nature through his charisma.


Agatha Christie's Poirot (title card).png Villains

Alfred Inglethorp | Alistair Ravenscroft | Ann Shapland | Anne Meredith | Bella Tanios | Claude Darrell | David Hunter | Dorothea Jarrow | Dr. Geoffrey Roberts | Dr. James Sheppard | Elsa Greer | Evelyn Howard | Franklin Clarke | Gerda Christow | Jacqueline de Bellefort | Jane Wilkinson | Jessie Hopkins | Lady Westholme | Lanfranco Cassetti | Marthe Daubreuil | Martin Alistair Blunt | Michael Garfield | Miss Chadwick | Miss Gilchrist | Nick Buckley | Nigel Chapman | Norman Gale | Patrick Redfern | Rowena Drake | Simon Doyle | Sir Charles Cartwright | Stephen Norton | Superintendent Sugden
Short Stories
Marrascaud | Nurse Harris | Roger Havering | Zoe Havering

Villainous Victims
Abandoned Accomplices
Anne Morisot | Carlotta Adams | Eileen Corrigan | Leslie Ferrier
Lady Boynton | Lord Edgware | Simeon Lee
Angèle Blanche | Charles Trenton | Henry Reedburn | Leopold Reynolds | Louise Bourget | Madame Giselle
Lanfranco Cassetti | Mrs. Lorrimer | Paul Déroulard | Stephen Norton
John Christow | Linnet Doyle | Mrs. Clapperton | Paul Renauld | Sir Reuben Astwell

Accomplices & Others
Alice Cunningham | Anne Morisot | Big Four | Carlotta Adams | Christine Redfern | Countess Vera Rosakoff | The Crofts | Eileen Corrigan | Frances Cloade | Freddie Rice's husband | George Challenger | Henrietta Savernake | Leslie Ferrier | Madame Daubreuil | Miss Van Schuyler | Rowley Cloade

Sophie Hannah's Continuations
The Monogram Murders (2014): Jennie Hobbs | Nancy Ducane | Samuel Kidd

Adaptational, Homage & Non-Canonical
Agatha Christie's Poirot: Grace Springer | Harrington Pace | Marie McDermott | Sister Agnieszka |

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.