|This villain was proposed but was rejected by the community for not being heinous enough or lacks what is necessary to be a Pure Evil villain. Therefore, this villain shall be added to our "Never Again List", where proposed villains rejected by the community shall be placed to prevent future proposals of the same evil-doer. They can be proposed again (with the permission of an administrator) if new elements appear in their series that can change their status a non-PE villains.|
Any act of adding this villain to the Pure Evil category without a proposal or creating a proposal for this villain without the permission of an administrator will result in a ban.
|This article's content is marked as Mature|
The page Mature contains mature content that may include coarse language, sexual references, and/or graphic violent images which may be disturbing to some. Mature pages are recommended for those who are 18 years of age and older.
If you are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are free to view this page. Otherwise, you should close this page and view another page.
|“||Do you know what I got Alex? I got my friends, I got the team. I don't get to be all "boo-hoo I'm sad my friend died", I'm gonna put a bullet in my head so the whole world feels sorry for me. Jesus, you wave that gun around like I give a shit. I don't, man. If I sell out Bryce or lie either way my life falls apart. I got no one else on my side. I can't run home, that team's my home. Going to playoffs, winning state, being an athlete? That's not about fun, for me it's about survival. It's all I got. It's everything.||„|
|~ Monty telling Alex his motives for his crimes.|
|“||Nothing happened to you that hasn't happened to a hundred guys. It's nothing, get over it.||„|
|~ Monty refusing to apologize for assaulting Tyler.|
Montgomery "Monty" de la Cruz is the secondary antagonist of the Netflix Original series 13 Reasons Why. He serves as a supporting antagonist in the first season, one of the two main antagonists (along with Bryce Walker) of the second season, the main antagonist of the third season, and a posthumous antagonist in the fourth season.
Montgomery has been known to mess around and pick on the Baker's Dozens as a way to silence the victims of Bryce Walker any of the jocks in Liberty High along with eventually antagonizing Bryce Walker in the third season after the latter cuts ties with him.
He is portrayed by Timothy Granaderos.
Montgomery is casually vicious and callous to the other students (especially Tyler Down) and uses physical cruelty the most often, seemingly just for the pleasure of it. Despite his behavior, his status as a popular athlete in baseball protects him from any consequences within the school. He is a member of Bryce Walker's bully friends and is passionately loyal to him. This is proven in season 2 where he consistently tries to protect his friend Bryce Walker from facing legal consequences for his rape allegations, he goes as far as being an accomplice to his rape of Hannah Baker (who later killed herself partially because she felt she could not handle the trauma the rape caused her), and an attempted murder to Clay Jensen to keep him silent, to protect Bryce.
Later during season three, it is revealed that Monty does terrible things to others to release his anger towards his father while still being evil. He also falls in love with Winston, dating him in secret after saying sorry for beating him up. Later, Monty becomes a prime suspect in Bryce's murder as the narrative reveals that he started hating Bryce after Bryce, (whom was attempting to reform at this point), threatened him for raping Tyler. Eventfully, after Tyler confesses to the students that he was a survivor during Jessica's speech and tells the police, Monty gets arrested for not only the rape, but also the murder of Bryce despite the fact that Alex performed the deed. As it turns out, to absolve Alex, the group and possibly Alex's father, framed Monty as his murderer. At the end of the season, it is revealed that Monty was found dead in his cell.
In season four, Winston and Diego Torres try to gain justice for Monty being framed for a crime he did not commit. He is present throughout Clay's hallucinations alongside Bryce. His sister Estela also begins attending Liberty High and mourns her brother's death, despite having knowledge of his horrid actions. While Monty's death isn't shown, news of his crime had spread throughout the jailhouse. He was labelled as a child rapist by the other inmates and was stabbed to death for what he did to Tyler.
Monty initially comes off as a very one-dimensional person. He is a cruel, sadistic, unsympathetic and naturally violent bully, most likely because of his abusive history with his father. His violent tendencies may also be a result of his abuse of steroids as well. As the audience learns more of his past, the narrative makes it clear that Monty's cruelty while inexcusable, is the result of his poor upbringing and possible self-loathing. The fourth season also reveals that despite rarely caring for anyone else, he did love his sister.
In the second season, Montgomery's character is shown to be more than just a one-dimensional bully. Monty is a manipulative and scheming survivalist, willing to side with whoever he believes will keep him safe even if the person is guilty. While Monty is extremely loyal to his friends and teammates, especially Bryce, it is not out of care or compassion but rather as a necessity because he believes that they are his best chance at surviving his abusive home. Even though Monty knows Bryce is guilty of raping multiple girls he still sides with him because of Bryce's family's influence and therefore his best chance of survival, despite knowing Bryce would never go the lengths Monty went to help Monty. He shows neither sympathy nor empathy towards any of his victims or Bryce's victims. He also goes a step further when he rapes Tyler with a mop stick in the high school bathroom on top of smashing his head against the mirror out of spite for the baseball season being cancelled.
In Season 3, he is still violent and psychopathic but slightly more subdued than in season two, as well as being revealed to be a repressed homosexual. He also becomes even more paranoid when the police begins to search the sports teams lockers for drugs, particularly steroids. Though he remains completely callous and heartless towards others, such as mocking Justin's drug addiction, Clay for being a suspect in Bryce's murder, as well as making kissing noises at Tyler after his rape of him. Monty's psychopathic behavior becomes so disturbing that even Bryce, who has committed a fair amount of atrocities, is disturbed and appalled at Monty's actions if only because Bryce himself started to become a better person. Though, we do see a few humanizing moments for Monty, such as seeing his abuse from his father as well as his repressed homosexuality, as well as showing a softer side to Winston such as genuinely apologizing to him for beating him up the last time they hooked up and opening up to him about his feelings, which shows that his virulent and obsessive homophobia is likely a result of some sort of self-loathing that he hides deep inside through his sadistic cruelty.
At the end of the day, Monty is a product of his environment, causing pain onto others to mask his own insecurities. He is still evil, but he is still capable of showing respect towards others and feeling remorse even though he rarely does. It's possible that if not for his death, he would have find more ways to project his anger towards his father that didn't involve harming others. On the other hand, he still died without showing any remorse or making any attempts at redeeming himself for his actions. Therefore, he remains mostly unsympathetic despite becoming a far more complex character than he was in the first two seasons.
- Mr. de la Cruz - Father
- Unnamed mother
- Estela de la Cruz - Sister
- Winston Williams - Former Lover
- Charlie St. George - Former Friend
- Scott Reed - Former Friend
- Diego Torres - Former Friend
- Justin Foley - Former Friend turned Enemy, threatened during Hannah Baker trial
- Bryce Walker † - Former Best Friend turned Enemy and Blackmailer
- Alex Standall - Former Friend turned Enemy, threatened during Hannah Baker trial
- Jessica Davis - Enemy, threatened during Hannah Baker trial
- Clay Jensen - Enemy and Attempted Victim
- Hannah Baker † - Harassed, and Indirect Victim
- Zach Dempsey - Former Friend turned Enemy, threatened during Hannah Baker trial
- Tyler Down - Enemy, bullied and raped
- Marcus Cole - Enemy
- Ani Achola - Enemy
- Tony Padilla - Enemy; vandalized car
This season Montgomery is the least villainous and he is mostly an antagonist because of his brutish nature. However, later seasons reveal that he is more involved with what goes on than one might think
At one of Liberty High School's school dances, he goes up behind Courtney Crimsen and forces himself on her body, asking her sexually for some fun later on, although he does stop touching her when she pushes him off.
Later, Montgomery was driving recklessly with Justin Foley on their way to school where he almost hits Alex Standall. Remorseless, he laughs vacuously in response to Alex angrily yelling that people were walking. The two then get in a fight, which Montgomery easily overpowers, and later Montgomery is suspended for 3 days.
After his suspension, Montgomery torments Tyler Down despite the latter's unprovoking actions. He once shoves Tyler to the floor when he passes him in the hall, and another time pins Tyler against the wall and threatens to break Tyler's expensive cameras against Tyler's face. Alex steps in and Montgomery backs off. This is his final antagonistic appearance in the season.
Montgomery is a villain in this season and many consider him the main antagonist (even more than Bryce Walker) of the season. As one of Bryce's friends, he goes at great lengths to protect Bryce from any legal consequences due to the rape accusations Bryce faces. Montgomery's deeds consist of:
- Giving out hostile notes and papers to the people who received subpoenas, telling them to stay quiet.
- Attempting to hit Clay Jensen with Bryce's jeep, which almost certainly would have killed him if he succeeded.
- Attempting to force Alex Standall (a recent suicide survivor) to kill himself by leaving a bullet in his locker and also a diagram of a target shooting dummy, and later a gun.
- Leaving a naked female sex doll on Jessica Davis' (who was raped by Bryce Walker) porch, hanging from a noose, calling her a slut.
- Defacing Tony Padilla's car, which he loves.
- Vandalizing the Bakers' drugstore, spraying words like "She's dead" in order to taunt them about Hannah's death.
When he is confronted, he ditches the crippled Alex Standall in an abandoned building and snatched the gun Alex had. Later it is revealed that he witnesses Bryce Walker raping Hannah Baker from inside Bryce's pool house, however he chose to not intervene and remained silent about it without a shred of guilt.
He vows for revenge on Tyler Down when the latter indirectly ends baseball season abruptly before state by vandalizing the baseball field. When he tells Bryce his plan, Bryce refuses to help him. He then abandons Monty which leaves him even further unhinged.
Later he and two of his lackeys run into Tyler Down in the boys bathroom. Angry at Tyler for ruining the season, he accuses Tyler of ruining his life then assaults him by smashing the back of Tyler's head into the mirror, breaking it. He then proceeded to slam him head first on the side of one of the sinks. He vulgarly calls Tyler a faggot and begins shoving Tyler's head in the toilet while Tyler cries out that he's sorry repeatedly. Montgomery then tops it off by shoving the end of a mop in the bathroom up Tyler's anus while his two lackeys hold Tyler down, thus anally raping him. He pushes the stick so far up Tyler's anus that it bleeds and he later is revealed to be unable to defecate without bleeding. Montgomery and his two friends leave Tyler behind in tears and agony, not knowing that this was the last straw for Tyler and they indirectly pushed him so far he decides to go through with his plan to shoot up the school at their Spring Fling Dance. Thankfully, Clay talked Tyler down and prevented him from shooting anyone.
Montgomery takes a less active role in this season than he did in season two. He harasses Tyler on occasion, showing no regret over raping him and mocks Clay for being the prime suspect of Bryce's murder and Justin for still consuming drugs. He also refuses to say sorry to Tyler, telling him to "get over" being raped.
When Bryce takes him to a "rich kid" party, he meets a boy named Winston Williams and the two briefly hook up. As Montgomery and Bryce are about to leave, Winston tries to speak with Montgomery, inviting him to hang out later on. Out of fear of being outed, Montgomery calls him a faggot and beats him senselessly. As a result, Bryce is forced to pay out a total of 7000$ to Winston in exchange for his silence.
On the night of Bryce's murder, Monty apologizes to Winston for beating him up and he invites him over to his house where they have sex, though Monty continues insisting he's not gay. Monty is finally arrested for his sexual assault on Tyler. Monty's father visits him in prison and angrily scolds him, not only for the crime itself, but for assaulting a male. He warns Monty that he will get beaten up by the inmates for what he did and Monty finally stands up to his father for the first time, saying that while he may get beaten in prison, he won't by his own father for once. He then asks Monty if he's gay, which he bravely admits, before the man spits on his face in response before turning to leave.
The group subsequently frames Monty for Bryce's murder in order to protect the true culprit - Alex Standall - before being informed that Monty was killed in his cell hours ago. Feeling sorry that Monty and Bryce are dead, Ani nonetheless convinces Deputy Standall to close the case by blaming the murder on Monty and that they should "let the dead bury dead". Despite his cruel nature, Monty was mourned by Clay and his friends as even they felt he didn't deserve to die. Winston, who is also upset about Monty's death, confronts Ani about lying to the police, since he knows Monty is innocent and he didn't deserve to die like he did. For now, it is unknown who murdered Monty or whether his father is involved. It's also unknown if Winston would gain justice for him.
- Ironically, despite playing such an active role in later seasons, Montgomery is not even on the tapes. This is despite how he, along with Alex did nothing while Bryce was raping Hannah and in Monty's case, enjoying it. However, it's possible that Hannah was somehow not aware that Monty was present, or that she was more hurt by Alex's failure because he was a friend of hers. Either way, him not being on the list confused viewers with some even saying that it's a plot hole.
- Montgomery de la Cruz was a really close friend to Bryce Walker. Bryce would cover for his negative behavior with Winston Williams. Justin Foley even says that both he and Monty cared for Bryce at some point. That being said; Monty ended up hating Bryce for blackmailing him after Tyler's rape, even though he still mourned him after his death.
- This confirmed that Monty did truly care for Bryce, and didn't just see him as a way to escape his abusive home life.
- Montgomery is more of a sociopath since he has been traumatized throughout his childhood possibly from his father as implied and pointed out. This would explain his sadistic behavior and constant homophobia towards others, despite engaging in homosexual activities himself which would make him a hypocrite. It also explains his lack of empathy from those affected by his and Bryce's actions.
- Montgomery has internal homophobia and would get insecure and angry towards others because of his abusive homophobic father. This would make Montgomery de la Cruz have more of an insecure side to him. One could even argue that his father's treatment of him is the reason he rarely shows compassion for others. However, the narrative as with most of the characters, still paint his way of coping in a way that makes Monty highly unsympathetic.
- Like with Bryce, Monty gaining a more sympathetic side resulted in an outcry among most fans. While even those who hated him the most felt he didn't deserve getting framed for a crime he didn't commit, a lot of people including some who supported Bryce, were furious that Monty suddenly showed some moments of compassion. Others were even more upset that Monty barely even tried to change his ways unlike Bryce; even stating that him saying sorry to Winston for beating him up was one of the few good deeds he performed after raping Tyler. Some even outright stated that they felt that while he didn't deserve getting framed for murder, he deserved dying because of his actions. Overall, his "nicer side," was one of the most disliked aspects of the third season.