Villains Wiki

Hi. This is Thesecret1070. I am an admin of this site. Edit as much as you wish, but one little thing... If you are going to edit a lot, then make yourself a user and login. Other than that, enjoy Villains Wiki!!!


Villains Wiki

Click To Help Darkseid!
Darkseid has declared that this article requires immediate Cleanup in order to meet a higher standard.
Help improve this article by improving formatting, spelling and general layout - least it fall victim to an Omega Effect

Stop hand.png

Woah, Loser! You might not wanna read your diary out loud; we can hear you.
~ Pencil telling Loser that he might not wanna read his diary out loud, and saying that she and the other eliminated contestants can hear him.
Ruby: Do I... press it?
~ Ruby and Pencil.

Pencil is an antgonistic contestant in the YouTube series Battle for Dream Island that has competed in every season of the show to date until The Power of Two. She was presented as one of the more enthusiastic contestants, being best friends with Match, and often adding "OMG" to her sentences.

Despite her nice behavior early on into the show's life, she was rather rude to Bubble and Ice Cube in Battle for Dream Island. She was later presented as an antagonistic protagonist in Battle for Dream Island Again.

She is also the tritagonist of Battle for Dream Island: The Power of Two.


Pencil appears to be a No. 2 graphite pencil, a pencil most commonly used for writing. Her tip is beige, her graphite is a dark gray, and her main body is three shades of orange. Her metal is silver, and her eraser is pink. Between BFDI and BFDIA, her eyes and mouth were moved closer together.


Pencil, along with Match, was one of the first 2 contestants seen on-screen in the very first episode of the show, Take the Plunge. Pencil is depicted as acting somewhat like a teenage girl, similar to Match, but less to an extent. Pencil often likes to add slang abbreviations to her sentences and has an inseparable best friend, Match.

Pencil was overall nice in the show until the third episode of Battle for Dream Island where she ridicules Bubble for being dumb and her "inability" to count to 3, which was proven true when she died before she reached 3.

In Battle for Dream Island Again, she revolts from Team No-Name and forms a team with her alliance, FreeSmart. From there, her more antagonistic side was shown, such as cheating by helping another contestant (Match) avoid elimination, bullying Ruby to tears, and referring to Book and Ice Cube as "monsters".

In IDFB, Pencil seems to be more detached from her relationships, as seen when she insults Match, her best friend, behind her back while she was eliminated.

In Battle for BFDI, Pencil becomes a control freak and toxic leader, taking advantage of Bubble's nature as a pushover in order to keep her under her thumb. She is also sadistic and sociopathic and will go out of her way to torture contestants that she hates, as seen when she stops Bubble from going against "the alliance's objective" so she could watch Fanny being electrocuted for her own amusement. She is later shown to be a misandrist, as she expresses disgust when a group of male contestants enter the EXIT.


Pencil was created during summer of 2008 as a character in the "Firey" comic book series. She later competed in a precursor to the show in a comic book series known as "Total Firey Island", in which she won the "show". She competed in yet another prototypical version of Battle for Dream Island known as "Total Firey Points", but her placement is unknown.

Pencil made her official debut in Battle for Dream Island as a contestant on the Squishy Cherries. She bullies Ice Cube and Bubble for not being good enough. She was eliminated in the nineteenth episode, Rescission, because of the Double-Digit overlap returning her score to 5.

Pencil returned in Battle for Dream Island Again. Her alliance was still going strong, and had expanded to include Book and Ruby, two new characters. She was still rather mean, by allowing Match to eject Book and Ice Cube from the Clubhouse of Awesomeness, and her bullying was especially prevalent during BFDIA 5, with making her friends cry and feeding Rocky to the Fish Monster multiple times.

Pencil survived to be in IDFB. It is then revealed that (maybe) she never really cared for Match that much and called her "Needy".

Pencil returned in Battle for BFDI, and uses Lightning to electrocute people she didn't like, such as Spongy and Flower. Bubble attempts to stop her, but Pencil threatens her status as by demoting her from a "member to bember" of her alliance. FreeSmart officially dissolved when Book and Ice Cube left to join a different team because they thought that it was unhealthy for them, leaving only her more close members of her alliance, Match, Bubble, Ruby, and herself. She was eliminated in the second episode due to her astonishingly mean behavior for the past 4 years (especially the first episode of BFB) and when she was up for elimination for the first time in 4 years, she was voted off the show and sucked into the EXIT.

However, when Spongy was eliminated, she and Match refused to go through him when everyone else goes, presumably because they still hate him due to being gross.


BFDI: Aw Seriously?


  • She got first place in Total Firey Island.
    • Coincidentally, she has placed dead last of the 65 competitors in BFB.

Navigation Pencil in the Heroes Wiki

            Object Show Villains

Announcer | Evil Leafy | Flower | Four | Two | Match | Pencil | Golf Ball | Bugs

Inanimate Insanity/Inanimate Insanity II/Inanimate Insanity Invitational
Steve Cobs | Taco | Nickel | MePhone4S | MePhone5 | MePhoneX | Pepper | Salt | Evil Paper

Brawl of the Objects
The Hacker | Controller | Battle Of The Objects

Object Mayhem/Object Mayhem II
Evil Tune | Football | Gun | Headphones

Object Universe/Object Twoniverse
Basketball | Evil Window | Reliving TV

Challenge To Win
Indigo Planet | Rainbow Doll

Excellent Entities/Extraordinarily Excellent Entities
Chocolate Bar | British Gummy Bear | Feather | Diary | Unicorn Horn

Object Invasion
Ethan | Mace

Paper Puppets/Paper Puppets Take 2
Mr. Hand | Blue Monsters

Battle for Luxurious Hotel

Object Towel Again
Anxiety | Crystaly | Grey Guy


STRIKE | Director

Battle for Trillion Dollars
Red Pen | Pump | The Creature

The Object Show Movie
Toxic Waste | Fruit Cake | Frying Pan

Objects at Gaming