This Villain was proposed and approved by Villains Wiki's Pure Evil Proposals Thread. Any act of removing this villain from the category without a Removal Proposal shall be considered vandalism (or a futile "heroic" attempt of redemption) and the user will have high chances of being terminated blocked.

Two-Toed Tom is a legendary alligator said to inhabit swamps of the Southeastern United States. Reportedly, the creature wreaked havoc during the 1900s, leaving trails of corpses in its wake. An alligator of gargantuan size, Two-Toed Tom is described as being akin to a demon, deriving its name from the fact that it had lost toes from previous attempts on its life.


Stories began to circulate in the 1920s in regards to Two-Toed Tom; this story was eventually recorded by the University of Alabama professor, Carl Carmer, whilst he was visiting the area to write his travelogue. Locals described the beast as measuring 4.5 meters in length, and that it had been hunting the town for decades. While alligators are commonplace to the community, this alligator had been actively hunting and consuming livestock in stark contrast to the normal behavior conveyed by other alligators. Some have even indicated that Two-Toed Tom was no mere alligator, explaining that it possessed red glowing eyes, and was immensely powerful, being able to even tear a horse to shreds in one swift thrash of its teeth. As rumors spread, the alligator was seen as a demon that was sent from Hell. Having sinister intentions for those that encounter it, not only does Two-Toed Tom massacre livestock and civilians, but it was also believed to rape women that were alone in the swamps. A trail of two-toed footprints were the defining signs that the creature was on the loose.

So the story goes, locals decided to take matters into their own hands, and they set out to destroy the beast. A hefty bounty was placed on the alligator, but it was proven nigh impossible to kill as it would just shake off whatever was thrown at it. Apparently, Two-Faced Tom was also rather intelligent, being able to avoid its would be captors with every turn. The beast would go on to wreak havoc for 20 years. Arguably the worst account was of Pap Haines, a former who had bought 40 acres of land. Despite being told that the legends surrounding the famed alligator were myths, Pap discovered that one of his mules was torn apart, and that trails of two-footed paw prints and blood led to a pond. Realizing that Two-Toed Tom must've been close, he decides to put an end to the monster once and for all. With the help of his sons, Pap fills 15 syrup buckets with sticks of dynamite, and began tossing them into the pond. The pond is completely destroyed by the buckets of dynamite, leaving it seemingly impossible for anything to survive. However, screaming was heard from a nearby pond, and the group comes face to face with the grisly remains of Haines' 12 year old granddaughter, who had gone out to see what all of the commotion was about. Concluding that Two-Toed Tom most likely knew about their intentions, Haines would continue his vendetta with the vicious alligator, and ultimately dies bitter and unfulfilled.




Folklore, religions, and myths
A-mi’-kuk | Abaddon | Abyzou | Aka Manto | Akkorokamui | Angra Mainyu | Ares | Asmodeus | Asuras | The Antichrist | Atlas | Aye-aye | Baal | Bandits | Banshee | Baphomet | Baron Samedi | Basilisk | The Beast | Behemoth | Behemoth the Elephant | Belphegor | Bigfoot | Black Cats | Black Monk of Pontefract | Black Rock Witch | Black Shuck | Blair Witch | Boneless | Buer | Cain | Cockatrice | Crom Cruach | Cthulhu | Damballa | Delilah | Demiurge | Demons | The Devil | Devil Monkeys | Dog-headed Men | Doppelgangers | Dybbuk | Eight Feet Tall | El Charro Negro | El Silbon | Enma Daio | Escornau | Fallen Angels | Fairies | Fenrir | Fossa | Fouke Monster | Foxes | Ghost Trains | Ghosts | Giants | Giants of Voronezh | Goliath | Great Old Ones | Green Witch | Gremlins | Grim Reaper | Groundhogs | Hades | Hags | Haman the Agagite | Harpies | The Headless Horseman | Hel | Herod Antipas | King Herod | Herodias | Horsemen of the Apocalypse | Hræsvelgr | Iblis | J'ba Fofi | Jezebel | Jörmungandr | Jötunn | Judas Iscariot | Kali | Kali | Kelpie of Loch Ness | Kappa | Keyser Söze | King Ahab | King Arthur | Kroni | Kronos | Krampus | Kuchisake-onna | La Cegua | La Llorona | La Sayona | La Viuda | Legion | Leviathan | Lilith | Loki | Lucius Tiberius | Mackenzie Poltergeist | Madman Marz | Mahishasura | Malsumis | Mammon | Mara | Mares | Mark Slender | Meg of Meldon | Mephistopheles | Michigan Dogman | Moloch | Morgan le Fay | Nure-Onna | Ogres | The Pharisees | Paparrasolla | Pesanta | Poltergeists | Rakshasa | Ravana | Rich Man | Romans | Samael | Santa Compaña | Satan | Saul | Sawney Bean | SCP Foundation | Set | Silas Scratch | Six Demons | Skeleton | Slender Man | Stolas | Succubi | Tailypo | Tarasque | Termagant | Titans | Trolls | Unholy Trinity | Vampires | Victor Crowley | The Rake | The Watchers | Water Horses | Whore of Babylon | Wolves | Xolotl | Zozo

Urban Legends (Common)
Amanda the Doll | Bunnyman | Bye Bye Man | Candyman | China Doll | Clown Doll | Cropsy | Crying Boy | Hairy-Armed Woman | Hook Killer | John & Susan Buckley | Joliet the Haunted and Cursed Doll | Licking Maniac | Melon Heads | Men In Black | Mystery Killer | Nain Rouge | Nameless Thing of Berkeley Square | Old Man Try-By-Night | Peeping Tom | Rain Man | Robert the Doll | Paimon | Patasola | Skinned Tom | Teke Teke | The Killer In the Backseat | The Man Upstairs

Urban Legends (Cryptids)
Beast of Gévaudan | Black Eyed Children | Black Stick Men | Bloop | Cherufe | Chupacabra | Devil Monkeys | Dog-headed Men | Fairies | Fallen Angels | Fear Liath | Flatwoods Monster | Ghosts | Goatman | Greys | Hoop Snake | Jersey Devil | Kelpie of Loch Ness | Kongamato | Kraken | Loch Ness Monster | Malawi Terror Beast | Mamlambo | Manananggal | Maricoxi | Mngwa | Momonjii | Mothman | Nobusuma | Pope Lick Monster | Popobawa | Pukwudgies | Reptoids | Roc | Ropen | Salawa | Sea-Serpents | Shadow People | Slide-Rock Bolter | Spring Heeled Jack | Tanuki | Thunderbird | Two-Toed Tom | Water Horses | Yeti | Yowie

Modern Legends
Charlie | Bloody Mary | Bloody Mary | Momo | Orie Chef | Herobrine

Creepypasta Villains

SCP Foundation
SCP Foundation Villains


Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.