Snape Uchiha Snape Uchiha 8 days ago

Should some GOT PEs be removed

I've been thinking and I've been considering doing some pure evil removal proposals for one of more Game of Thrones characters.

Here is a quote from the Pure evil criteria.

A Song of Ice and Fire/Game of Thrones has a massively high heinous standard which includes mass murder, rape, mutilation, torture, child murder/rape etc. It should be very difficult for any one villain to qualify as PE. Yet on this website it has among the most PE characters of any franchise, including:

Ramsay Bolton
Joffrey Baratheon
Gregor Clegane
Euron Greyjoy
Walder Frey
Karl Tanner

If that is not enough, there is significant discussion about adding more, such as Aerys II Targaryen.

It is understandable why these characters were added, as their crimes are horrific. Th…

Read Full Post
Snape Uchiha Snape Uchiha 19 October

PE Proposal: Cluny the Scourge

For this PE proposal, we are going to discuss Cluny the Scourge from Redwall. A few notes before we begin.

1) He had previously been under the category (though not certified), but the page was deleted for plagiarism. I am trying to re-add him for the category.

2) I had previously argued that Redwall villains lack moral agency since certain species are born either good or evil. However, the majority of users voted that they do in fact have moral agency, so, by majority rule, I am going forward with the premise that Redwall villains do indeed have moral agency.

3) I am talking about the novel version, so I won't be addressing things like him massacring Matthias's village.

  • 1 What's the Work
  • 2 Who is he?
  • 3 What has he done
  • 4 Heinous Standards
  • 5 Mitigating …

Read Full Post
Snape Uchiha Snape Uchiha 13 July

Pure Evil Proposal: Vee Parker (Orange is the New Black)

So for this proposal, we are talking about Yvone "Vee" Parker  from the Netlix series Orange is the New Black.  

  • 1 What's the Work
  • 2 Who is she? What has she done
  • 3 Heinous Standard
  • 4 Mitigating Factors
  • 5 Final Verdict

Orange is the New Black is a television show which is loosely based on a memior called "Orange is the New Black: My Life in a women's prison", by Piper Kerman. The show follows a fictional version of Piper Kerman called Piper Chapman, as well as many other characters, such as the deuteragonist of the show, Taystee Jefferson, who are inmates in a woman's prison called Litchfield Penitentiary. 

Yvonne Parker, more commonly known as Vee, was the main antagonsit of season 2. She was a drug dealer who would recruit orphan children and make t…

Read Full Post
Snape Uchiha Snape Uchiha 2 July

Pure Evil Proposal: Biff Tannen (Back to the Future)

For this proposal, I am talking about Biff Tannen from Back to the Future. This will be a bit confusing as Biff appears ]in several different time periods and timelines. However, he is really just the same character with different resources.

  • 1 What's the Work?
  • 2 Who is he/What has he done
    • 2.1 1955
    • 2.2 1985
    • 2.3 1985B
    • 2.4 1985A
    • 2.5 2015
  • 3 Heinous Standard
  • 4 Mitigating Factors
  • 5 Final Verdict

Back to the Future is a science-fiction comedy trilogy about a teenager named Marty McFly and a Scientist named Dr. (Doc) Emmett Brown. Doc invented a time machine in a Delorean and the two travel though time, often accidentally messing up timelines which they then need to fix. On their adventures, they often run into some version of Buford (Biff) Tannen, or his ancestor/desc…

Read Full Post
Snape Uchiha Snape Uchiha 27 June

Pure Evil Proposal: Opal Koboi Artemis Fowl Film

Note: I am not white-listed, but I got permission from Sirin to make this proposal.

I am proposing Opal Koboi from the Artemis Fowl film as PE. The book version is already PE, but now I want to discuss the film version. (Actually I don’t really want to discuss it, because I hated the film and the character, but I’m doing it anyway).

  • 1 What’s the Work
  • 2 Who is she? What has she done?
  • 3 Heinous Standard
  • 4 Mitigating Factors
  • 5 Final Verdict

‘’Artemis Fowl’’ is a science Fantasy film based on the book series of the same name. In this film a young aristocrat named Artemis Fowl II discovers that there is a hidden fairy world. He must rescue his father from a fairy named Opal Koboi who wants a Macguffin called the Aculos. In his efforts to rescue his father,…

Read Full Post

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.