They resemble classic, modern werewolves, although simply by tearing away tufts of fur, they transform into more civilized versions of themselves. After this transformation, they wear grey suits and glasses. It has been seen that some Why-wolves have two heads with one eye on each.
In the episode "Donny," while Finn and Jake were trying to help Donny stop being a jerk, Finn hears a call for help from the house people to discover vicious wolves attacking them. He tries to fight them back and manages to toss two of them into a well. Finn wonders what is with the wolves when one of them in the well changes into a business suit and explains.
He says they are Why-Wolves are trying to wipe out the house people to they populate. The Why-wolves are usually kept in check by Obnoxygen, a gas produced by Donny the ogre that is deadly to Why-wolves. However, if left unchecked, the Why-wolves would eat the House People and grow in population until they attract the Cosmic Owl, who will subsequently devour them.
Finn then rushes back to the tree house to find Donny changed. So, he and Jake try to get him to be a Jerk again by making fun of him. This causes everyone both the house people and the why-wolves to laugh at him. This makes him so mad that he reverts back to being and jerk and produces Obnoxygen driving the wolves away.
- According to a post on the Frederator Blog, Marceline's dress in "Henchman" is made from Why-wolf skin. Ironically, Marceline turned into a wolf to scare Jake.
- Their species name is a pun on "Werewolf".
- Mostly likely, the cosmic owl is their natural enemy.
- The lecturing Why-wolf's tone and cadence are reminiscent of those of the narrators of a series of science education films produced by Bell Labs in the 1950s and 1960s that were often shown in schools and on educational television through the 1970s.